By making a purchase through the links provided, you have the opportunity to earn us a commission. Please note that the products or services advertised on this page may be offered by a company affiliated with us. You can find more information about this by visiting this link.
In the realm of online sleep products, Tuft & Needle and Helix stand out as two highly successful companies. Alongside their popular mattress lines, they also offer a range of bed frames, bedding, and other sleep accessories.
Tuft & Needle holds the distinction of being one of the pioneers in the mattress-in-a-box movement, and their success continues to this day. They currently offer three different mattresses: the Original and Mint models, both of which are made entirely of foam, and the Tuft & Needle Hybrid.
In contrast, Helix has adopted a unique approach by designing a lineup of mattresses that caters to the specific needs of different types of sleepers. Customers can conveniently take a brief sleep quiz on their website to determine which mattress would be the most suitable for their preferences. In total, Helix sells six hybrid mattresses, each with its own distinctive characteristics: Sunset, Moonlight, Midnight, Dusk, Twilight, and Dawn. Additionally, these mattresses are also available in a more luxurious Luxe version, offering extra features to enhance the sleeping experience.
Our comprehensive guide comparing Tuft & Needle and Helix mattresses provides detailed specifications, sleeper ratings, and other practical information to assist you in making an informed choice during your search.
We have invested significant effort in presenting you with the mattresses that align best with your needs. Take a look at our complete mattress guides listed below!
Price Range for Queen Size:
Firmness Options:
– Medium (5)
– Medium Firm (6)
– Soft (3)
– Medium Soft (4)
– Medium Firm (6)
– Firm (7)
– Firm (8)
Distinct Features:
For Tuft & Needle:
– Their proprietary foam provides contouring along with a quick response to pressure.
– Graphite and gel infusions help regulate temperature.
– Their mattresses are competitively priced compared to others on the market.
For Helix:
– They offer a variety of mattresses specifically designed to suit various types of sleepers.
– Their sleep quiz assists customers in determining their ideal firmness level.
– They provide below-average prices and offer a choice between basic or luxury features.
Models:
Sleep Trial & Warranty:
– 100 nights
– 10-Year Limited Warranty
- 100 nights (minimum requirement of 30 nights)
- 10 Year, Limited Warranty
Customer Support
Exclusive Offer from the Sleep Foundation!
Ready to make a purchase? Check out the Tuft and Needle mattresses.
Start Shopping Now!
Get 25% off mattresses plus 2 free pillows.
Start Shopping Now!
When it comes to buying a new mattress, you have the opportunity to make significant changes to your bedroom setup. This could mean upgrading to a larger bed or optimizing space by downsizing. Regardless, it’s important to carefully consider not only the size of the mattress, but also its height and weight.
A heavy mattress can be more challenging to set up, rotate, and move. If you struggle with lifting heavy objects or anticipate moving the mattress around, it’s advisable to focus your search on mattresses that are easier to handle.
The height of the mattress is particularly important for individuals who may have difficulty getting in and out of bed. Don’t forget to account for the height of the foundation when determining how high the mattress will sit above the ground. If you opt for an extra-tall mattress, you may need to invest in deep-pocket fitted sheets.
When purchasing a mattress for an existing bed frame or foundation, pay close attention to the exact measurements. Some mattresses may have slight variations in length or width, which can create unsightly gaps between the mattress and the foundation.
Size Options:
– Twin
– Twin XL
– Full
– Queen
– King
– California King
Options in Different Sizes
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Tuft & Needle presents a collection of only three mattress options, but these encompass a vast array of preferences. They offer a basic all-foam mattress, a more luxurious all-foam model, and a hybrid mattress. All of the Tuft & Needle mattresses are available in the standard six mattress sizes, with profiles that range from average to slightly above average in height. As expected, the hybrid mattress is heavier compared to the other two due to its innerspring support core.
On the other hand, Helix offers a total of twelve mattresses, including the Luxe models. However, the choices are more limited when considering height and weight. All of their mattresses are hybrid models that weigh more than the average all-foam model. The mattress profiles are also taller than the average, with the Luxe mattresses measuring in at an impressive 14 inches. Similar to Tuft & Needle, every Helix mattress is available in the six standard mattress sizes.
While you can’t fully gauge the comfort of a mattress without sleeping on it for a few nights, you can still gain insight into its performance by examining its materials and design. Most mattresses utilize a basic design consisting of a comfort section placed over a support core.
The comfort layers of a mattress are what the sleeper directly interacts with, so they are typically made of cushioning or conforming materials such as memory foam, latex, polyfoam, or even micro-coils. On the other hand, the support core provides a stable surface that promotes proper spinal alignment. As a result, this section usually features sturdier materials like innerspring coils, firmer latex, or high-density polyfoam.
Mattresses with a similar overall design tend to exhibit shared characteristics. For instance, all-foam mattresses are renowned for their excellent motion isolation and pressure relief, while hybrid mattresses are known for offering a balanced feel due to the combination of a thick comfort layer section over an innerspring base. However, aside from these significant differences, each mattress has its unique quirks resulting from its distinct design.
Tuft & Needle produces three mattress models: The Original, The Mint, and The Hybrid. All three mattresses incorporate at least one layer of the company’s exclusive Adaptive Foam, which provides moderate pressure relief while responding quickly to pressure. Each mattress also features a breathable cover made of a blend of micro polyamide and polyester.
Tuft & Needle mattresses hold certifications from CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold, attesting to their absence of harmful chemicals.
The Original
The Tuft & Needle Original is an all-foam mattress consisting of 3 inches of their proprietary Adaptive Foam on top of a 7-inch high-density polyfoam support core. The Adaptive Foam contains graphite and gel infusions that efficiently dissipate heat, while the open-cell foam in the base layer allows for heat ventilation.
With a medium firmness level, The Original appeals to the majority of sleepers. It offers a well-balanced combination of support and pressure relief.
The Mint
The Mint is an upgrade from the Tuft & Needle Original, incorporating an additional 2-inch layer of transitional polyfoam. It also includes additional graphite and ceramic gel beads for enhanced temperature regulation and pressure relief. The Mint features an improved cover with antimicrobial protection. To prevent sagging along the edges, a 4-inch perimeter of extra-firm foam is included in the support core.
Thanks to its thicker comfort layer section, The Mint is the ideal choice for side sleepers and those seeking extra pressure relief. The Mint’s cover includes unique features not found in other Tuft & Needle mattresses. An embedded antimicrobial protectant in the fabric helps fend off harmful bacteria, and the top half of the cover can be conveniently removed and machine washed.
The Versatile Blend
The Tuft & Needle Hybrid Mattress showcases a top layer of 1-inch polyfoam adorned with graphite and carbon fiber infusion, coupled with 2 inches of graphite and ceramic gel-infused Adaptive Foam. Like its counterparts in the Tuft & Needle collection, these comforting layers effectively dissipate heat and offer gentle contouring with swift responsiveness to pressure.
Underneath the plush pillow top, the Hybrid boasts a coil-on-coil construction featuring a layer of micro-coils measuring 1 inch, followed by a 6-inch pocketed coil base. Separating the two is an inch of Adaptive Foam. This innovative design both enhances airflow and establishes a lively surface, ideal for amorous activities or individuals who alternate sleep positions. The independent movement of the pocketed coils lends superior motion isolation compared to traditional innerspring models.
Furthermore, the mattress incorporates robust coils encircling the perimeter, ideal for couples who prefer ample personal space. A solid foundation is provided by an inch of high-density polyfoam.
Helix presents a diverse selection of six hybrid mattresses, each meticulously tailored to cater to specific types of sleepers. The company’s proprietary foams, including:
- Memory Foam Plus: This foam, utilized in the comfort layers of the Helix mattresses, embraces the body to relieve pressure. It exhibits varying levels of firmness across different mattress models.
- Helix Dynamic Foam: Engineered as an alternative to traditional polyfoam or memory foam, Helix Dynamic Foam ensures rapid response to pressure. This foam is incorporated in the first and second layers of Helix mattresses to deliver delightful resilience. As with Memory Foam Plus, Helix Dynamic Foam is available in different firmness options according to the specific mattress model.
- High-Grade Polyfoam: This firm foam acts as an effective transition layer to the support core.
Each mattress is enveloped in a breathable polyester cover and features an 8-inch support core of pocketed coils. These coils, which are characteristic of hybrid designs, provide buoyancy and facilitate airflow to maintain a neutral temperature all night. Two rows of reinforced coils guard against edge sagging, while a high-density polyfoam base cradles the coils in place.
In addition to the standard mattress line, Helix offers the Luxe edition of each model, boasting additional advantages. These mattresses present a quilted pillow top adorned with a Tencel cover, elevating the overall height by 2 inches. Tencel, renowned for its moisture-wicking properties, ensures a cool surface. Furthermore, Luxe mattresses offer targeted support with zoned coils that are firmer in the lumbar region and along the perimeter of the bed.
Luxe mattresses are a suitable choice for individuals who prioritize motion isolation and pressure relief. However, due to their plush comfort layers, they may retain slightly more heat, and those who frequently switch positions during sleep may find some of the softer Luxe models mildly restrictive.
Helix mattresses carry certifications from CertiPUR-US and OEKO-TEX Standard 100, guaranteeing their freedom from harmful substances.
While the Helix mattress lineup may initially appear intricate, it is surprisingly straightforward. The six mattresses encompass one soft, one medium soft, two medium, and two firm options. Within each firmness level, one mattress features a memory foam top layer specially optimized for side sleepers, while the other incorporates a firmer Helix Dynamic Foam layer, ideal for stomach and back sleepers.
Soft:
Helix Sunset (for side sleepers)
- Memory foam (Memory Plus Foam)
- Latex-like polyfoam (Helix Dynamic Foam)
- Pocketed coils
- Polyfoam
Medium Soft:
Helix Moonlight (for back sleepers)
- Latex-like polyfoam (Helix Dynamic Foam)
- Latex-like polyfoam (Helix Dynamic Foam)
- Pocketed coils
- Polyfoam
Medium Firm:
Helix Midnight (for side and back sleepers)
- Memory foam (Memory Plus Foam) – a type of foam that contours to the body’s shape and provides excellent pressure relief and motion isolation.
- Transition polyfoam (High-Grade Polyfoam) – a high-quality foam that helps to enhance comfort and support during the transitions between different layers of the mattress.
- Pocketed coils – individually wrapped coils that provide targeted support and minimize motion transfer.
- Polyfoam – a type of foam that adds cushioning and support to the mattress.
Helix Dusk (ideal for side sleepers)
- Latex-like polyfoam (Helix Dynamic Foam) – a foam that mimics the feel of natural latex, offering a responsive and supportive sleep surface.
- Pocketed coils – individually wrapped coils that provide targeted support and minimize motion transfer.
- Polyfoam – a type of foam that adds cushioning and support to the mattress.
Firm:
Helix Twilight (suitable for back and stomach sleepers)
- Memory foam (Memory Plus Foam) – a type of foam that contours to the body’s shape and provides excellent pressure relief and motion isolation.
- Transition polyfoam (High-Grade Polyfoam) – a high-quality foam that helps to enhance comfort and support during the transitions between different layers of the mattress.
- Pocketed coils – individually wrapped coils that provide targeted support and minimize motion transfer.
- Polyfoam – a type of foam that adds cushioning and support to the mattress.
Helix Dawn (suitable for back and stomach sleepers)
- Latex-like polyfoam (Helix Dynamic Foam) – a foam that mimics the feel of natural latex, offering a responsive and supportive sleep surface.
- Transition polyfoam (High-Grade Polyfoam) – a high-quality foam that helps to enhance comfort and support during the transitions between different layers of the mattress.
- Pocketed coils – individually wrapped coils that provide targeted support and minimize motion transfer.
- Polyfoam – a type of foam that adds cushioning and support to the mattress.
Each mattress possesses distinct advantages that cater to certain sleepers, as well as drawbacks that may render it unsuitable for others. For instance, a mattress that conforms closely to the body can excel in relieving pressure and isolating motion, but it may hinder temperature regulation by trapping heat. By understanding how the following factors influence the feel of a mattress, you can narrow down your options and find the perfect match for your sleeping preferences.
Longevity
A mattress’s longevity primarily depends on the quality of its materials. Inferior materials are prone to breaking down, leading to diminished pressure relief and support over time, necessitating a replacement. While it may not be necessary to splurge, it may be worthwhile to invest a little more to ensure your mattress remains effective throughout its average lifespan of 6 to 8 years.
Motion Isolation
If you are easily disturbed by your sleeping partner’s movements or late-night bathroom trips, it is crucial to find a mattress with excellent motion isolation. Sleepers who are sensitive to any disruptions often prefer materials like memory foam that react locally to pressure, preventing it from transferring across the bed, unlike traditional innerspring mattresses.
Intimacy
A mattress should not only cater to sleep but also contribute to a satisfying intimate experience. Preferences vary when it comes to sexual activity, although many individuals find that a mattress with some bounce, such as a hybrid or latex model, is ideal. Additionally, strong edge support and temperature neutrality are important considerations for couples. Lastly, individuals with thin walls may benefit from a mattress that is silent and free from creaking sounds.
Temperature Neutrality
Overheating during sleep can be uncomfortable, especially for hot sleepers. If you struggle with heat retention from your mattress, there are numerous options available. These include hybrid or innerspring mattresses with breathable coil layers, temperature-neutral latex mattresses, and even all-foam mattresses that incorporate cooling gels and other innovative technologies. Breathable cover materials and a surface that doesn’t closely adhere to the body can also aid in temperature regulation.
Pressure Relief
One of the key functions of a mattress is to provide pressure relief. This entails relieving pressure on common points such as the hips and shoulders, as well as other areas like the lower back, which often experiences additional strain due to lack of support. To achieve optimal pressure relief, a mattress must be appropriately firm to contour to the sleeper’s body type and preferred sleeping position. Some mattresses employ zones with varying levels of firmness and softness, targeting different areas of the body more effectively.
Odor
It is common for new mattresses to emit a slight odor when unpacked. This phenomenon is known as off-gassing and results from the release of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) into the air. Allowing the mattress to air out for a few days typically eliminates the odor entirely. If you are particularly sensitive to odors, you may feel more comfortable with an all-natural mattress that does not contain synthetic polyfoam or memory foam.
Mobility Benefits
While many sleepers enjoy the traditional sensation of being enveloped by an all-foam mattress, it can become constricting when changing sleeping positions. Combination sleepers often prefer mattresses that incorporate latex or innerspring coils, as these provide a more responsive feel that supports movement. Active sleepers who are set on purchasing an all-foam mattress will find a firmer model more suitable, allowing them to stay “on” rather than sinking “in” the bed.
Support at the Edges
A common issue with mattresses is sagging around the edges, which tends to worsen over time. If you prefer sitting on the edge of the bed, one option is to choose a mattress with reinforced edges. This feature provides a sense of security not just while sleeping, but also when getting in and out of bed. Many hybrid mattresses come with reinforced edges in the form of stronger coils or a polyfoam encasement.
There are several factors that impact the price of a mattress, and not all of them are immediately apparent. Elements such as design, material quality, special features, additional certifications, and country of manufacture all contribute to the pricing.
While price and quality are often linked, this is not always the case. It’s important to avoid favoring a more expensive mattress solely based on its price. A better approach is to make a list of the features that are important to you and find mattresses within your budget that meet those criteria.
It’s worth noting that it is uncommon to pay the full price when buying a mattress, especially online. Many companies frequently offer discounts that can significantly reduce the final cost, often amounting to a few hundred dollars. These discounts are often available for extended periods, spanning from one major holiday to the next, so it is usually advisable to wait for the latest promotions before making a purchase.
Special Offer from Sleep Foundation
Use this SleepFoundation.org link to access the most up-to-date discount on Tuft and Needle mattresses.
Special Offer from Sleep Foundation
Get a 25% discount on mattresses and receive 2 free pillows.
The flagship Tuft & Needle mattress is priced well below the average for a quality all-foam mattress. Even the Mint mattress is reasonably priced, comparable to other all-foam mattresses on the market. The Mint also boasts a long lifespan, making it great value for money. While the Hybrid model is slightly more expensive, its price remains in line with the average hybrid mattress.
Standard Helix mattresses are also highly affordable compared to other hybrid options, providing an attractive choice for budget-conscious shoppers. For those willing to spend more, the Helix Luxe mattresses offer a premium experience at a competitive price point within their category.
100-night Trial Period (30-night minimum)
When purchasing a mattress online, it is customary to receive it as a mattress-in-a-box, which involves shrink-wrapping, compressing, and shipping it in a cardboard box. Once the mattress arrives at your home, simply place it on the foundation and remove the plastic to allow it to expand.
Mattress-in-a-box shipping is typically free within the continental U.S. and delivery times can range from a few business days to a few weeks. Additional charges and longer delivery times may apply for orders to Hawaii, Alaska, and international destinations.
Some companies offer optional White Glove delivery, where a third-party provider sets up the mattress in your desired room and removes the packaging materials. This service typically incurs an extra fee and may not be available for orders outside the continental U.S. White Glove customers may also request their old mattress to be removed for an additional charge.
Helix provides free shipping to all 50 states, with an additional charge of $250 plus customs fees for orders to Canadian provinces. White Glove delivery is available in the contiguous U.S. for a fee, and old mattress removal can be arranged for an extra charge.
Tuft & Needle offers free shipping in the contiguous U.S. through FedEx Ground. Same-day shipping is available for an additional fee in select locations for the Original and Mint mattresses. Orders to Hawaii and Alaska incur an extra shipping charge. Tuft & Needle does not ship to Canada, but the Original mattress is available on Amazon.ca. White Glove delivery and old mattress removal are available in the contiguous U.S. for an additional fee of $150.
When purchasing a mattress online, it is standard to receive a sleep trial of at least 90 nights. During this period, if you find that you are dissatisfied with the feel of the mattress, you can return it for a full refund. Keep in mind that shipping charges, White Glove delivery fees, and additional costs are typically non-refundable.
If a mattress is returned, the company will usually arrange for it to be picked up and responsibly donated or recycled.
Tuft & Needle mattresses purchased directly from their website come with a 100-night sleep trial. Tuft & Needle will work with customers to donate the mattress locally or have it recycled, and a full refund will be provided. Mattresses purchased through third-party distributors may have different return policies.
Helix also offers a 100-night sleep trial, but requires a minimum break-in period of 30 nights. Customers who decide to return the mattress between the 30th and 100th night will receive a full refund. For those who wish to try a different firmness level, Helix offers a free comfort layer instead of a mattress return.
Mattress warranties safeguard consumers against defects in manufacturing and workmanship, such as premature sagging, foam splitting or cracking, and cover flaws. These warranties generally require the mattress to be used with a properly supportive foundation and do not cover damage caused by misuse or abuse.
Typically, mattress warranties are included in the price and last for at least 10 years. Some warranties may be prorated, meaning that after a certain period of time, customers are responsible for a portion of the repair or replacement costs.
Tuft & Needle provides a 10-year limited, non-prorated warranty that covers defects, including permanent indentations of at least 3/4 inch. The company will replace or repair defective mattresses, or customers have the option to upgrade to a more expensive model by paying the price difference.
Standard Helix mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty, while Luxe mattresses have a 15-year warranty. Both warranties cover defects, including permanent indentations of at least 1 inch. Customers may be responsible for shipping charges. Similar to Tuft & Needle, Helix allows customers to upgrade to a better model by paying the price difference instead of receiving an identical replacement.
