When you make a purchase using our provided links, we may receive a commission. The products or services advertised on this page may be offered by an affiliated entity. To find out more, click here.
Before investing in a new mattress, we strongly encourage you to thoroughly research and compare various brands and models. This will help you find the perfect fit for you and your partner, if applicable. Comparison shopping allows you to evaluate different mattresses based on factors such as cost, construction, and customer satisfaction. You can also compare shipping, return, and warranty options offered by different companies to minimize additional expenses. In this review, we will analyze two leading online mattress brands in the United States: Saatva and WinkBeds.
Saatva has been operating since 2010 and their flagship product is the Saatva Classic mattress. This mattress takes a modern approach to the traditional innerspring design. It features a Euro-top padding layer with cushioning from foam and dacron fibers, as well as comfort layers made of polyfoam and memory foam. Additionally, there is a transitional layer of pocketed microcoils over a support core composed of recycled steel bonnell coils. The coil-on-coil design of the Saatva mattress provides excellent responsiveness and support. You can choose from three different firmness options: soft (3), medium firm (6), and firm (8). The Saatva mattress is available in two different profiles: 11.5-inch and 14.5-inch.
Saatva also offers three other mattress models. The Saatva HD is designed for individuals weighing over 230 pounds and features an organic cotton pillow-top, zoned Talalay latex, high-density memory foam, a transitional polyfoam layer, and an offset coil support core. With a firmness level of 7, this mattress has a 15.5-inch profile. The Saatva Youth is a reversible innerspring mattress suitable for children aged 3 and above. One side of the mattress has a medium (5) feel, while the other side offers a firm (7) feel. Lastly, the Saatva Latex Hybrid consists of a Talalay latex comfort layer and a pocketed coil support core. This particular model provides a medium firm (6) feel.
WinkBeds, founded in 2016, presents the WinkBed mattress as their flagship product. It is a hybrid mattress that bears similarities to the Saatva innerspring. The standard WinkBed includes a gel-infused polyfoam comfort layer and a second layer of pocketed microcoils. The support core is made up of pocketed coils that are divided into different zones based on coil thickness, ensuring minimal sinkage when getting in and out of bed. The standard WinkBed is available in three firmness options: medium soft (4), medium firm (6), and firm (7-8). WinkBeds also offers the WinkBed Plus, which is specifically designed for individuals weighing over 230 pounds. This variant replaces the microcoil layer with 2.5 inches of responsive, zoned latex.
Additionally, WinkBeds offers two other mattress models. The GravityLux is a mixed-foam mattress that consists of polyfoam and memory foam comfort layers, along with denser polyfoam in the transitional and support layers. Like the standard WinkBed, it comes in three firmness levels: medium soft (4), medium (5), and firm (7). The EcoCloud is a latex hybrid mattress with 4 inches of Talalay latex over a pocketed coil support core. This mattress provides a medium (5) feel.
Continue reading to discover the detailed comparison between Saatva and WinkBeds in terms of size and weight, construction and materials, prices, and performance ratings in different categories.
Please note: This comparison guide exclusively focuses on Saatva mattress models that carry the Saatva name. It does not cover additional Saatva models, including the Loom & Leaf memory foam mattress, the Zenhaven flippable latex mattress, and the Solaire adjustable airbed.
We have put in considerable effort to help you find the mattress that suits your needs. Check out our comprehensive mattress guides listed below for more information!
Price Range (Queen):
Options for Firmness
Soft (3), Moderate (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7), Firm (8)
Medium Soft (4), Moderate (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7), Firm (8), Plus (8)
Key Features
– Supportive and responsive coil mattresses
– Breathable components ensure consistent temperature regulation
– Durable designs and high-quality materials
– Zoned coils prevent excessive sinkage along the perimeter
Models
Sleep Trial & Warranty
– 365 Nights ($99 Return Fee)
– Lifetime, Limited
– 120 nights (30-night requirement)
– Lifetime, Limited
Customer Service
Exclusive Offer from Sleep Foundation!
Before selecting a model, it is important to carefully consider the desired mattress size. Nowadays, most available mattresses come in six standard sizes. These include twin, twin XL, and full for single sleepers, as well as queen, king, and California king for couples or multiple individuals. Additionally, some models offer split sizes specifically designed for adjustable bed bases.
Thickness is also a crucial factor to take into account. For those who prefer sleeping closer to the ground, a low-profile mattress (less than 10 inches in height) may be ideal. On the other hand, a high-profile mattress (taller than 12 inches) provides extra padding for individuals in need of greater contouring and support.
Lastly, it is advisable to check the weights of mattresses before ordering from a mattress-in-a-box brand. These companies deliver mattresses directly to your doorstep, and it can be challenging to carry a box weighing over 100 pounds.
Complete details regarding weight, thickness, and sizes for Saatva and WinkBeds mattresses are provided below.
Size Options
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, Split California King
Size Options
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Size Options
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King
Options for Sizes
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Choices for Sizes
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King
Varieties of Sizes
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Range of Sizes
Twin, Twin XL, Full
Assortment of Sizes
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
As you can observe, Saatva presents a wider array of mattress options compared to WinkBeds in terms of thickness and size. The Saatva Classic delivers the greatest versatility. In addition to an 11.5-inch medium profile and a 14.5-inch high profile, you can select from the six standard sizes as well as split king or split California king for an adjustable base. Both the Saatva HD and Saatva Latex Hybrid are also available in a split king, although not in a split California king. The Saatva Youth, tailored towards children, is exclusively offered in twin, twin XL, and full sizes.
All three models from WinkBeds are accessible in the six standard mattress sizes, without any splits. Each of these beds is provided in one profile as well.
Given that innerspring and hybrid mattresses generally tend to be relatively heavy, it should come as no surprise that most Saatva and WinkBeds models designed for adults weigh at least 110 pounds in queen size. The exception here is the GravityLux, which has a much lighter weight due to its all-foam construction. One important thing to remember is that since Saatva solely offers White Glove delivery, you won’t have to carry a Saatva mattress on your own to set it up.
The specifications regarding construction and material composition can provide significant insights into a mattress. Most online mattress brands include these details on their official product pages, and possibly elsewhere on their website such as an FAQ section.
Modern mattresses consist of four components: top comfort layers that provide cushioning and contouring to the body, middle transitional layers to prevent excessive sinkage, a base support core for stability, and a cover that encases the entire mattress. Each component plays a role in the overall feel of the bed, as well as its performance in different categories.
Full details regarding the construction and materials for all Saatva and WinkBeds mattress models are listed below.
The Saatva Classic innerspring mattress starts with a Euro-top layer quilted with polyfoam and fiber padding. Despite the Saatva’s supportive design, the Euro-top adds some extra plushness to its surface. Euro-tops are seamlessly sewn to the edges to create a uniform appearance for the mattress.
The mattress also includes comfort layers of polyfoam and memory foam, along with a transitional layer of pocketed minicoils. These foam layers provide contouring, as do the minicoils. As a result, you’ll experience more cushioning from the Saatva compared to more traditional innerspring mattresses that often have minimal foam padding layers. The coils also contribute to the bed’s springy and responsive feel.
The support core of the Saatva consists of bonnell (or hourglass) coils made from recycled steel. These coils have a gauge of 13, which is quite thick, and provide very strong reinforcement even by innerspring standards. The 11.5-inch Saatva model has a 4-inch bonnell coil layer, whereas the 14.5-inch model has a 7-inch coil layer. These differences in coil layer thickness, weight, and overall thickness are the only distinctions between the two Saatva profiles.
When it comes to the Saatva mattress, you have the option to select from three different levels of firmness: soft (3), medium firm (6), or firm (8). These firmness levels vary slightly in terms of the amount of padding in the Euro-top and comfort layers.
The Saatva HD is designed with a pillow-top that is padded with organic cotton, providing a surface that offers comparable cushioning to the flagship Saatva mattress. The first layer of comfort is made from Talalay latex, a material known for its conforming and responsive qualities. The latex is divided into five zones of firmness, providing extra support in areas such as the midsection and waist, while offering gentle conformity around the head, neck, shoulders, and legs. A second layer of high-density memory foam adds additional contouring and strong support.
The Saatva HD also features a transitional layer of high-density polyfoam and a support core made from recycled steel offset coils. These layers ensure excellent stability and edge support, making it ideal for individuals weighing more than 230 pounds. The coils also contribute to the overall responsiveness of the mattress. If you and/or your sleep partner weigh more than 230 pounds, the Saatva HD will provide a comfortable and supportive sleep experience. Its thickness measures 15.5 inches, making it a taller model, and it is considered firm (7) in terms of its feel.
Introducing the Saatva Latex Hybrid, the newest addition to Saatva’s mattress collection. This model features a 3-inch comfort layer of Talalay latex, a material that conforms to the body while offering increased bounce and reduced sinking compared to memory foam. The latex also promotes cool sleeping thanks to ventilation holes that enhance airflow to the surface.
The support core of the Saatva Latex Hybrid consists of pocketed coils arranged in a zoned configuration. Thicker, lower-gauge coils line the perimeter of the mattress to protect against excessive sinkage when getting in and out of bed, while thinner, higher-gauge coils provide gentle cradling beneath the sleep surface. With a medium firm (6) feel, this mattress offers strong support for individuals weighing more than 130 pounds.
Lastly, we have the Saatva Youth, a mattress specifically designed for children aged 3 and older. This flippable innerspring mattress offers a different firmness level on each side. The first side is medium (5) and features a comfort layer of zoned polyfoam, providing support in heavier areas and enhanced padding where needed. Saatva recommends this side for children between the ages of 3 and 7.
The second side has a firm (7) feel and offers increased support, making it ideal for children aged 8 and older. This side’s comfort layer consists of egg-crate polyfoam, providing additional support and comfort. The Saatva Youth features a shared support core made from 14.5-gauge bonnell coils. It is important to note that this 10-inch mattress is only available in twin, twin XL, and full sizes.
All Saatva mattresses come encased in organic cotton covers.
Moving on to the WinkBed, which, like the Saatva, is a coil-on-coil mattress known for its highly responsive feel. The medium soft (4) version of the WinkBed has a top comfort layer of gel-infused polyfoam, a secondary comfort layer of pocketed microcoils, and a transitional layer of high-density polyfoam. The medium firm (6) and firm (7-8) versions of the standard WinkBed have the same first two components but do not include the transitional layer.
The support core of the medium soft WinkBed consists of pocketed coils divided into five gauge zones. Thicker coils line the edges to prevent excessive sinkage, while thinner coils offer gentle support to the body. For the medium firm and firm WinkBeds, this layer is divided into seven gauge zones for the same effect. As you can see, the firmness options for the standard WinkBed and the Saatva are quite comparable.
Next, we have the WinkBed Plus, which is specifically designed for individuals weighing more than 230 pounds. This firm (8) mattress includes a polyfoam comfort layer and a transitional layer of zoned latex. With its responsive and supportive properties, latex provides reinforced support in heavier areas of the body and minimal sinkage, regardless of body type. The WinkBed Plus also features a support core made from pocketed coils, divided into three gauge zones. Both the WinkBed and WinkBed Plus mattresses have a thickness of 13.5 inches.
Overall, Saatva and WinkBed offer a range of mattresses to suit different preferences and needs, ensuring a comfortable and restful sleep experience for various body types and weights.
The EcoCloud also falls into the category of a hybrid mattress. It features a 4-inch layer of Talalay latex for added comfort and responsiveness, while still contouring to your body. The latex is designed with small perforations to promote consistent airflow near the surface. Although hybrids typically sleep cool, the EcoCloud surpasses expectations in temperature regulation with its breathable comfort layers. In addition, this mattress includes a zoned pocketed coil support system and a base layer of high-density polyfoam. It measures 12.5 inches thick and has a medium firmness rating of 5.
On the other hand, the GravityLux stands out among other WinkBeds models as an all-foam mattress. Its construction consists of a cover quilted with 2 inches of polyfoam padding, a comfort layer of memory foam, and transitional and support layers made with high-density polyfoam. Compared to WinkBed hybrids, the GravityLux provides a deeper body contour, which can be further customized by selecting a medium soft (4), medium (5), or firm (7) feel. At a thickness of 12 inches, the GravityLux is unique as WinkBeds’ only medium-profile mattress.
The EcoCloud boasts a cover crafted from a blend of organic cotton and wool. This material combination ensures exceptional breathability and moisture-wicking properties from the wool to keep you dry. In contrast, other WinkBeds mattresses feature covers made of Tencel lyocell, a fabric known for its breathability and luxuriously soft texture.
Each mattress excels in certain areas while facing challenges in others. Some models excel at pressure relief and motion isolation but may retain heat and lack edge support. Conversely, some mattresses may have excellent temperature neutrality and edge support but struggle with motion isolation. Performance in specific categories often depends on factors such as thickness, firmness, and material composition.
The following are our performance ratings for both Saatva and WinkBeds mattresses. Let’s begin by explaining each category and how we assess mattresses for these aspects.
Durability – On average, mattresses typically last between six to eight years before needing a replacement. Over time, beds tend to soften, lose support, and develop uncomfortable sagging or deep body impressions on the surface. If the edges start to sink, it may be time to consider a new mattress, especially if getting in and out of bed becomes challenging. Rotating the mattress head-to-foot every three to six months can help extend its lifespan.
Motion Isolation – When you move on or off the bed or change sleep positions, your movements can create motion transfer that disrupts your partner. Responsive mattresses tend to generate more transfer and increase the chances of sleep disturbances. In contrast, less responsive models absorb motion and minimize transfer. In general, all-foam mattresses offer superior motion isolation, while innerspring and hybrid mattresses are more prone to transfer.
Sex – According to most couples, the ideal mattress for sexual activity should provide a slight contour for good traction while remaining responsive. This combination enables you and your partner to maintain comfortable positions for extended periods while allowing effortless movement across the surface. Additionally, having adequate edge support is crucial to maximize the usable mattress space and avoid feeling confined to the middle.
Temperature Neutrality – Certain mattress materials, especially high-density foams, can absorb and trap body heat, resulting in an excessively warm surface. Conversely, other components offer enhanced breathability and airflow to maintain a comfortable temperature. These components include aerated foam, latex, coil systems that facilitate air circulation, and covers infused with cooling fabrics and natural fibers.
Pressure Relief – If you frequently experience pressure points in specific areas of your body, it’s essential to find a mattress that supports the shoulders, midsection, and hips without excessive sinking. The level of pressure relief varies depending on your body type and sleep position. For example, a side sleeper weighing less than 130 pounds requires a different mattress than a back or stomach sleeper weighing more than 230 pounds. Ultimately, the best way to determine which mattress offers optimal pressure relief is through testing and personal experience.
Off-Gassing: Upon unpacking your mattress, you may notice initial odors. This is referred to as off-gassing. Mattresses with foam layers are particularly susceptible to emitting volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are tiny particles that carry a chemical odor resembling plastic. Latex mattresses also have a distinctive rubbery smell. The good news is that most mattress odors will dissipate within a few days. However, if the odors persist, you can try placing the mattress in a well-ventilated room for an additional one to two nights.
Mobility: Soft mattresses that tend to sink may present difficulties when it comes to movement. As you get in and out of bed or change sleeping positions, you may feel trapped beneath the surface of the mattress. The ease of movement of a mattress varies depending on your weight. Individuals weighing more than 230 pounds will likely find it more challenging to move on a softer mattress compared to those weighing less than 130 pounds.
Support at the Edges: When sitting on the edges of a mattress, you may experience slight sinkage. Mattresses with support systems composed of sturdy materials like steel coils offer better bounce-back, reducing sinkage. On the other hand, mattresses with foam or latex support cores typically result in more sinkage, making it less secure to sleep near the perimeter.
The cost of a new mattress depends on various factors, including the chosen size, materials used in the construction of different layers, and the brand itself. In a queen size, the average cost of an innerspring or all-foam mattress is $1,200 or less, while a hybrid mattress ranges from $1,600 to $2,200.
The purchasing location can also impact the price of a mattress. Buying from a physical store often entails higher costs due to their higher overhead expenses. Conversely, online brands that operate with fewer or no physical stores can offer the same mattresses at lower prices.
Aside from the mattress cost, it’s important to carefully review a mattress company’s shipping, trial, and warranty policies. This will help you avoid additional delivery charges, return fees, prorated warranty replacement charges, and other unexpected expenses.
The tables below provide the current prices for each available size of Saatva and WinkBeds mattresses.
Special Offer from Sleep Foundation:
– 15% off orders of $1,000 or more
– Get $300 off all mattresses
For budget-conscious mattress shoppers, the Saatva Classic and Saatva Youth are both great options. The Saatva Classic offers a comfortable balance of cushioning and support, surpassing other similarly constructed models, despite being slightly more expensive than the average innerspring mattress. The Saatva Latex Hybrid is a mid-range option that costs more than the Classic and less than the HD. The Saatva HD may have a higher price point, but it is exceptionally durable and serves as a valuable long-term investment, especially for individuals weighing over 230 pounds. Please note that the pricing for the Saatva Classic remains the same regardless of firmness and thickness selection in any size.
In comparison to other all-foam mattresses, the GravityLux is slightly more expensive than average, but still reasonably priced. Other WinkBeds mattresses may have higher price points, but they are on par with, or even lower than, the average hybrid model. The WinkBed Plus costs slightly more than the standard WinkBed, but the pricing remains unaffected by firmness for any WinkBeds model.
365-Night Trial with a $99 Return Fee.
Receive Complimentary White Glove Delivery in the contiguous United States.
Reap the benefits of a full 120 nights (with a 30-night minimum requirement) to test your dream mattress.
Saatva stands out among online mattress brands by offering all customers complimentary White Glove delivery. This exceptional service includes professional in-home assembly and the removal of your old mattress. Please be aware that Saatva exclusively delivers within the contiguous United States. Since our dedicated couriers will personally deliver your mattress, there’s no need for it to be compressed into a box during shipping. However, it’s important for you or another adult to be present at home when your mattress arrives.
WinkBeds also provides free ground shipping to all customers in the contiguous United States. This is a common delivery practice for mattress-in-a-box brands. Your WinkBeds mattress will be compressed, vacuum-sealed, and shipped in a compact box directly to your doorstep. You won’t have to worry about being home to sign for the delivery, but do expect to carry the box inside and assemble the mattress yourself. Within 48 hours of unboxing, your mattress should fully recover its original shape.
But that’s not all – WinkBeds also offers White Glove delivery! For a fee of $129, residents in the contiguous United States can enjoy professional mattress assembly. If you would like your old mattress removed as well, the fee increases to $189. It’s important to note that these delivery charges are non-refundable in the event of a mattress return.
One common concern when purchasing mattresses online is the inability to physically test the product before committing. To address this, most online brands now offer sleep trials that last 90 nights or even longer. If you find yourself unsatisfied with your mattress and wish to initiate a return before the trial period ends, the company will typically provide a refund for most, if not all, of the original mattress price.
Saatva generously offers a remarkable 365-night sleep trial. In comparison, WinkBeds offers a 120-night sleep trial. However, WinkBeds requires customers to use and “break in” the mattress for a minimum of 30 nights before initiating a return, while Saatva does not impose any mandatory break-in period.
In the event of a return, WinkBeds will issue a complete refund and handle the logistics of retrieving the mattress from your residence at no additional cost to you. Saatva also offers mattress pickups, but please be aware that the company does charge a $99 return fee.
Manufacturers provide warranties to take responsibility for any potential defects in their products. If an item covered by a warranty becomes defective before the warranty expires, the manufacturer (not the consumer) will cover the costs of repair or replacement. These days, most mattresses come with warranties that extend for a minimum of 10 years.
Every Saatva mattress comes with a lifetime warranty. During the first two years, Saatva will repair or replace any defective mattress completely free of charge. Starting from year three, Saatva will continue to provide repairs and replacements for a transportation fee of $99 each way. As an alternative, Saatva offers the “Fairness Replacement Option.” Under this agreement, you can keep your old mattress for free if you agree to pay a certain percentage of the original price should your mattress develop a defect and need to be replaced.
WinkBeds offers a lifetime warranty for all of their mattress models, ensuring coverage against defects for as long as you own the bed. If a defect arises, you will be responsible for shipping and transportation charges, while WinkBeds will cover all repair and replacement costs. Additionally, WinkBeds provides the “Any Reason” program, which allows you to replace your mattress with a different WinkBeds model at 50 percent of the original price once the sleep trial period has ended.
Under the Saatva warranty, body impressions on the mattress surface that measure 1 inch or deeper are considered defects. On the other hand, the WinkBeds warranty specifies that impressions must measure at least 1.5 inches in order to warrant free repairs or replacements.
Please note that these mattress warranties are non-transferable. You will only be eligible for warranty coverage if you purchase the mattress directly from Saatva or an authorized retailer. Buying or receiving the mattress from another owner or a non-authorized retailer will void the warranty.
