Battle of the Beds: Measuring Up Nectar and Tuft & Needle Mattresses in 2023

By clicking on the links provided in this article, you have the potential to earn a commission from the purchase. Please note that the products or services advertised on this page may be offered by a company in association with us. For more information, please visit our advertising disclosure page.

Nectar and Tuft & Needle are two prominent online mattress brands in the United States that offer mattresses that can be conveniently delivered in a compact box. While these companies have similar models in terms of their construction, materials, and firmness levels, there are distinct characteristics that set them apart.

Nectar made its debut in 2017 with its flagship mattress, the Nectar Mattress. This particular model is built with a layer of memory foam for optimal comfort, followed by polyfoam transitional and base layers. The mattress has a medium firmness level, which is suitable for a wide range of sleepers. Since then, Nectar has introduced two additional all-foam mattresses called the Nectar Premier and Nectar Premier Copper. These models also offer a medium firmness level, but they are slightly thicker than the original Nectar Mattress.

On the other hand, Tuft & Needle has been in the business since 2012. Their signature mattress, known as the T&N Original Mattress, is made entirely of polyfoam and features a 3-inch comfort layer and a high-density base. Tuft & Needle also offers the Mint Mattress, which has a top layer infused with graphite and cooling gel to prevent overheating during sleep. Both of these mattresses have a medium firmness level.

Tuft & Needle’s third mattress, the T&N Hybrid, combines a polyfoam comfort layer with a layer of minicoils, all supported by a pocketed coil support core. This unique coil-on-coil design provides enhanced responsiveness, making the T&N Hybrid slightly softer compared to the other Tuft & Needle mattresses.

If you have narrowed down your options to Tuft & Needle and Nectar, we hope that our detailed breakdown will assist you in finding the ideal brand and model for your needs.

We have invested a considerable amount of effort into providing you with information on the best mattresses for your specific requirements. Take a look at the comprehensive mattress guides we have listed below!

Price Range (Queen)

Firmness Options

Medium (5), Medium Firm (6)

Standout Features

– Adaptive memory foam that conforms to the body and relieves pressure

– Excellent motion isolation and noise reduction

– Premium polyfoam that contours to the body while maintaining responsiveness

– Open-cell material that promotes cooler sleeping

Models

Sleep Trial & Warranty

– 365 nights

– Lifetime, Limited

– 100 nights

– 10-Year, Limited

Customer Service

Exclusive Offer from the Sleep Foundation!

SPECIAL OFFER: Get $200 off and $499 worth of accessories included, for a total of $699!

Shop Now!

Enjoy a Spring Refresh Sale with 20% off bundles and 15% off mattresses.

Shop Now!

Nectar and Tuft & Needle provide a wide range of options when it comes to mattress weight, thickness, and sizing. They do not offer any specialty sizes like split queen or king, so you will need to choose from the six standard sizing options.

Weight is often overlooked when considering a mattress. In addition to setting up the mattress, it is recommended to rotate it head-to-foot every three to six months to protect the surface from body impressions. All mattresses are relatively heavy and may require more than one person to lift and move, but some models are bulkier and more cumbersome than others.

See also  Comparison of Saatva and Purple Mattress 2023

With the exception of the T&N Hybrid, all Nectar and Tuft & Needle mattresses are relatively lightweight. This is expected as beds with coil layers tend to weigh more than all-foam models. However, two people should be able to lift or move any of these mattresses, including the hybrid.

Size Options: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, and Split King.

A bed’s construction and materials greatly affect its firmness and other characteristics such as support, temperature regulation, motion isolation, and durability.

While each mattress model is unique, they typically consist of four main components. Comfort layers, located on top of the mattress, include materials like polyfoam, memory foam, latex, and others that provide cushioning and conform to your body. The transitional layer, situated beneath the comfort layers, prevents excessive sinking and is usually made of dense polyfoam or minicoils.

The support core, also known as the base layers, stabilize the mattress, keeping you on an even plane and preventing excessive sinking of the edges. The material used for the support core depends on the type of mattress and may include high-density polyfoam, latex, coil systems, or motorized air chambers. Many mattresses also have a bottom layer of high-density foam for added reinforcement.

Lastly, the mattress is encased in a cover made of fabric blends such as cotton, polyester, rayon, wool, and other fibers. While most covers are not removable, some can be unzipped and taken off for cleaning purposes.

Nectar Mattress

The extraordinary Nectar Mattress showcases a lavish 2-inch layer of memory foam for ultimate comfort, accompanied by a 3-inch transitional polyfoam layer. Embracing your body in a deep, cradling embrace, these two layers create a remarkable experience of sleeping “within” the mattress.

For unparalleled support, the mattress boasts a support core of 7 inches of high-density polyfoam. This remarkably firm and dense material ensures that while you may sink into the surface, the transitional and base layers will counteract excessive sagging. As a result, the Nectar Mattress measures an impressive 12 inches in thickness.

The cover of the Nectar Mattress is skillfully crafted from a delightful blend of polyester, polyethylene, and nylon, guaranteeing a heavenly soft and highly breathable surface.

Nectar Premier

Distinguished by its distinctive composition, the Nectar Premier diverges slightly from the flagship Nectar Mattress. Its comfort layer boasts 3 inches of gel-infused memory foam, supplemented with a phase-change material that dissipates heat and ensures a cool sleeping experience. With a 3-inch transitional layer and 7-inch base layer, the Nectar Premier achieves an overall profile of 13 inches.

Similar to the Nectar Mattress, the Nectar Premier offers a medium firm feel. However, the inclusion of the phase-change material grants the Premier the advantage of sleeping noticeably cooler. The Premier’s cover, like its predecessor, is created from a blend of polyester, polyethylene, and nylon.

Nectar Premier Copper

The illustrious Nectar Premier Copper, proudly the thickest in the collection at 14 inches, boasts a luxurious 4-inch comfort layer infused with gel and cleverly combined with phase-change material. A modest 1-inch transitional polyfoam layer and a 9-inch polyfoam support core complete this extraordinary mattress.

See also  The 2023 Comparison: Tuft & Needle vs. Helix Mattress

Promising a medium firm feel, the Premier Copper’s heightened stature and thicker comfort layer form a closer body contour for sleepers, distinguishing it from the Premier and flagship models. Additionally, the cover, enriched with cooling copper, ensures unparalleled temperature control for an exceptional sleeping experience.

T&N Original Mattress

Presenting a design that is both sleek and uncomplicated, the T&N Original Mattress embodies a medium firm feel. This model forgoes a transitional layer, revealing a 3-inch comfort layer of polyfoam resting atop a 7-inch high-density polyfoam support core. The open-cell polyfoam used in the comfort layer promotes enhanced breathability, preventing the accumulation of body heat commonly found in denser foams within other models. The infusion of graphite and cooling gel in the foam aids in countering heat buildup on the surface.

While the absence of a transitional layer may result in some individuals sinking too deeply into the T&N Original Mattress, its edges are prone to deep sagging, making it somewhat challenging to get on and off the bed, particularly for those weighing over 230 pounds.

Mint Mattress

With a profile of 12 inches, the Mint Mattress reigns 2 inches taller than the T&N Original Mattress, delivering a medium firm feel. Like its flagship counterpart, this magnificent mattress possesses a 3-inch polyfoam comfort layer infused with graphite and cooling gel. Additionally, it boasts a 2-inch transitional layer infused with the same cooling components. The inclusion of these exceptional cooling elements sets the Mint Mattress apart, guaranteeing a noticeably cooler sleeping experience compared to the T&N Original Mattress and other all-foam models by rival brands.

For its support core, the Mint Mattress relies on a high-density polyfoam layer that spans 7 inches. With the presence of a transitional layer, this mattress provides superior sleeper support and enhanced perimeter reinforcement in comparison to the T&N Original Mattress.

The cover, composed of a blend of micro polyamide and polyester, is embedded with an antimicrobial protectant designed to combat the effects of microbes, including harmful bacteria, thus enhancing the lifespan of the mattress. The top half of the cover can be conveniently removed and machine washed.

T&N Hybrid

Finally, the T&N Hybrid elevates your sleep experience by offering the same top comfort layer as the other esteemed Tuft & Needle models – adaptive, open-cell polyfoam infused with graphite and cooling gel. The second comfort layer is comprised of minicoils that conform to your body, maintaining an even plane. The minicoils, alongside a polyfoam transitional layer, contribute to an exceptionally responsive mattress, surpassing the responsiveness of other hybrids.

The support core of the T&N Hybrid features pocketed coils, providing formidable support to your body and the edges, surpassing the support offered by high-density foam. Additionally, both coil layers ensure a continuous airflow, facilitating temperature regulation and a comfortable sleep environment. With the T&N Hybrid, you can anticipate less sinking into the mattress compared to the other two Tuft & Needle models, presenting an excellent choice if you prefer a sleeping experience “on” rather than “in” the mattress.

All three mattresses produced by Tuft & Needle share a common feature – a cover that cannot be removed, made from a combination of polyamide, which is a durable fabric class encompassing nylon and Kevlar, as well as polyester.

See also  Comparing DreamCloud and Casper Mattresses in 2023

Every individual sleeper possesses unique preferences when it comes to mattresses. Some individuals desire a mattress that molds to their body, providing relief from pressure points and supporting the spine. Others prefer a firmer, more responsive bed. There are numerous qualities that potential buyers value when searching for a mattress. For instance, those who tend to sleep hot may prioritize finding a mattress that regulates temperature. Couples may focus on factors such as motion isolation, noise prevention, and edge support in order to narrow down their choices.

Durability

Typically, a mattress will remain functional for six to eight years before it requires replacement. Certain materials can prolong the lifespan of a mattress, such as high-density foam, organic or natural latex, and robust coil systems. In the case of newer mattresses that have not been on the market for an extended period of time, we assess their durability by considering the quality of their materials and construction, as well as consulting reviews from verified owners.

Motion Isolation

Certain mattresses possess comfort layers that effectively absorb motion from sleepers, preventing their movement from transferring across the mattress surface. This feature is highly desirable for individuals who share their bed with a partner, as it minimizes disturbances caused by shifting positions or getting in and out of bed. Conversely, mattresses that are more responsive and do not absorb motion can be disruptive for co-sleepers.

Intimacy

While personal preferences may vary, most couples prefer mattresses with good responsiveness and bounce for intimate activities. Mattresses that conform closely tend to sink too deeply, which can impede movement and make changing positions somewhat challenging. In addition, strong edge support is also important for this aspect of mattress usage. A mattress with robust perimeter support ensures minimal sagging, allowing you and your partner to utilize the entire surface without feeling confined to the center of the bed.

Temperature Regulation

A mattress that maintains a comfortable balance between coolness and warmth is considered temperature-neutral. This characteristic is often attributed to materials that promote internal airflow, such as coil systems and ventilated latex. Additionally, breathable cover materials like wool, organic cotton, and Tencel contribute to a comfortable temperature. Generally, firmer mattresses tend to sleep cooler than softer ones, as they allow for less sinking and increased airflow across the mattress surface.

Pressure Relief

The best mattresses for pressure relief are those that conform to the body while providing adequate support to the spine, without sinking too deeply. Mattresses that are excessively soft will likely sag beneath the torso, leading to the development of pressure points in the shoulders, lower back, and hips. On the other hand, mattresses that are excessively firm do not contour closely enough, resulting in pressure buildup in sensitive areas. The extent to which a mattress offers pressure relief varies depending on an individual’s body weight and preferred sleep position.

Odor Release

Almost every mattress emits a distinct odor when first unpacked from its shipping box. In most cases, these odors dissipate within a few days. However, some mattresses continue to release odors for a more prolonged period of time. Mattresses with polyfoam and/or memory foam layers tend to have a higher potential for emitting odors, as polyurethane foam produces volatile organic compounds (VOCs) that carry a chemical scent.

See also  Comparison of Layla Hybrid and WinkBeds Mattresses 2023

Ease of Movement

Ease of movement refers to how readily a mattress adjusts to the body and the extent to which its surface restricts movement. Softer mattresses with adaptive foam layers can be challenging to move on, while mattresses with responsive coil layers offer a more even surface for movement. It is important to note that ease of movement can also affect the overall experience on a mattress during intimate activities.

Edge Support

When sitting on the edge of a mattress, one may experience some degree of sinkage as the body compresses the mattress. Hybrids and innerspring mattresses with coil systems generally provide the strongest edge support. While some amount of sinkage is expected, these mattresses also offer pushback and support, unlike mattresses with foam or latex support layers. Mattresses with weak edge support can pose challenges when getting in and out of bed, and may not provide a secure feeling when sleeping near the edges.

The average cost of a queen-size mattress falls between $1,500 and $1,900. However, there are various factors that can influence the price of a mattress, including the type of mattress, the specific materials used, and the brand. While costs can vary significantly, each type of mattress tends to have a typical price range. Innerspring and all-foam mattresses are generally the most affordable options and can be widely found for $1,200 or less in a queen size. Hybrids and latex mattresses typically fall within the mid-level price range of $1,600 to $2,200. Airbeds, which are the most expensive type of mattress on average, often surpass $2,500 in a queen size.

Exclusive Offer from the Sleep Foundation

Get a 33% discount on all products with this special promotion from the Sleep Foundation.

Discover the Best Deals

There are great deals available on Tuft and Needle mattresses when you use this SleepFoundation.org link. Stay updated with the most current discounts.

Affordable Options

When it comes to pricing, Nectar and Tuft & Needle offer mattresses that are reasonably priced. The flagship models, Nectar and T&N Original Mattress, are particularly budget-friendly compared to other all-foam beds on the market. These models are cost-effective and have received excellent ratings in various categories.

High-Quality at a Good Value

While the Mint Mattress is slightly more expensive than the T&N Original Mattress, it still offers exceptional quality at a below-average price. The construction of this mattress makes it a worthwhile purchase.

Variety for Different Budgets

For those with a more flexible budget, there are options like the Nectar Premier, Nectar Premier Copper, or T&N Hybrid. These models come with a higher price tag but offer unique features. It’s important to consider the type of mattress you prefer. The Nectar Premier and Premier Copper are more expensive compared to other memory foam beds, while the T&N Hybrid is priced lower than the average hybrid model.

Convenient Shopping Experience

Both Nectar and Tuft & Needle are known as mattress-in-a-box brands. This means they compress their mattresses and ship them in compact boxes without damaging the product. Enjoy the convenience of free ground shipping within the contiguous U.S. using FedEx Ground. Delivery to Alaska and Hawaii is also available for an additional charge. Rest assured that your mattress will arrive within seven business days.

See also  Battle of the Bed: A 2023 Review of Bear vs. Casper Mattress

Fast Delivery Options

Tuft & Needle goes a step further by offering same-day delivery for customers in select U.S. cities for a flat fee of $50. This expedited shipping service is exclusive to Tuft & Needle and is not available from Nectar. Additionally, both brands provide White Glove delivery, which includes scheduled delivery, in-home mattress assembly, and old mattress removal. This service is only available to customers in the contiguous U.S. Nectar charges $149 for White Glove delivery, while Tuft & Needle charges $150.

Sleep Trial Comparisons

One notable difference between Nectar and Tuft & Needle is their sleep trial periods. Nectar offers an impressive 365-night trial, allowing you to truly experience the mattress. You’ll need to test out your Nectar bed for at least 30 nights before deciding, but after that, you can return it for a full refund or exchange it for another size or model. Nectar even provides a courier service to retrieve the mattress from your residence for recycling or donation.

Tuft & Needle’s sleep trial is 100 nights, which is shorter compared to Nectar’s trial but aligns with the average length. There is no mandatory break-in period, giving you the freedom to return your Tuft & Needle mattress at any point during the 100-night trial. Tuft & Needle provides a full refund for all returns. They encourage customers to recycle or donate the mattress themselves, but if that’s not possible, they offer a pickup service at no extra cost.

Durable Warranty Coverage

Nectar stands out with a lifetime warranty, offering coverage for as long as you own the mattress. The warranty is non-prorated for the first 10 years. If a defect occurs during this period, Nectar covers all repair or replacement costs, including transportation charges. After the initial 10 years, Nectar still provides significant coverage, but there is a flat shipping fee of $100 ($50 each way) for repairs or replacements.

On the other hand, Tuft & Needle offers a 10-year warranty. Although shorter than Nectar’s warranty, it is sufficient considering most mattresses are replaced within 10 years. This warranty is non-prorated, meaning if a defect arises at any point during the 10-year period, Tuft & Needle will repair or replace the mattress at no extra charge to the owner.

Understanding Warranty Terms

When reviewing a mattress warranty, pay attention to what is considered a defect. For Nectar, a body impression in the surface that measures 1.5 inches or deeper is recognized as a defect. For Tuft & Needle, the minimum impression depth is .75 inches. A Nectar mattress must have an impression twice as deep as a Tuft & Needle mattress to qualify for a repair or replacement.

Choose Wisely

Ultimately, it’s important to note that most mattresses will need replacement within eight years or less, regardless of the warranty length. Don’t be swayed by longer warranties when purchasing a more expensive mattress. In all likelihood, the extra coverage won’t be necessary.

Purchase your mattress confidently with the exclusive offer from the Sleep Foundation, ensuring a good night’s sleep for years to come.