By making purchases through our provided links, we have the potential to earn a commission. It is possible that products or services featured on this page may be offered by an affiliated entity. Discover more information here.
Tuft & Needle and Casper, two well-known mattress brands available online, have risen to prominence as disruptors in the traditional mattress industry. Instead of the conventional approach of buying mattresses from physical stores, these companies spearheaded the trend of online mattress shopping.
Both Tuft & Needle and Casper started their journeys with humble beginnings, initially offering affordable all-foam mattresses. As they gained traction and built strong brand reputations, they expanded their product offerings to include pillows, bedding, and bedroom furniture.
These industry leaders have also invested their efforts into designing new models of mattresses. On top of the Original Tuft & Needle, the company now offers the all-foam Mint and the newer Hybrid. Casper, on the other hand, has gone even further by introducing the Casper Hybrid, the straightforward Element, and the luxurious Wave Hybrid and Nova Hybrid options.
Given the strong online presence of both Casper and Tuft & Needle, it is common for customers to find themselves torn between these brands. However, with the expansion of their product lines, it has become increasingly challenging for shoppers to determine which mattress is ideal for their specific needs.
Each option has its own advantages and drawbacks, and it is important to remember that no single mattress is universally perfect for everyone. Instead, the best choice for you depends on your personal preferences and requirements. The following sections will provide you with crucial insights that can help you become a knowledgeable shopper and confidently choose the ultimate winner in the Tuft & Needle versus Casper heavyweight battle.
We have put in extensive effort to guide you towards the mattresses that are most suitable for you. Take a look at our comprehensive mattress guides listed below!
When considering a new mattress, it is vital to take practical factors into account. These include the mattress’s dimensions, weight, height, and size.
A heavy mattress can be burdensome to lift and transport. This consideration is particularly relevant for individuals who anticipate moving multiple times during the mattress’s lifespan.
Height carries two significant implications. Tall mattresses may require fitted sheets with extra-deep pockets to stay securely in place. Additionally, the total height of the bed, which encompasses both the mattress and the frame, can impact how easily you can get in and out of bed, making it especially relevant for individuals experiencing joint discomfort.
Size Variations
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Size Variations
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Options for Different Sizes
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Size Variety
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Size Preferences
Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
For both brands, hybrid mattresses are heavier compared to all-foam options. This is because of the added weight of innerspring coils. In the queen size, all hybrid mattresses from these companies weigh between 106 and 113 pounds.
All models come in the standard six mattress sizes: twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king.
The arrangement and materials used in each layer greatly influence the performance of a mattress.
A mattress consists of two main components: the support core and the comfort system. The support core is the lower section that provides stability and structural integrity to the entire mattress. It also acts as a solid foundation for the comfort system.
The comfort system comprises the top layers of the mattress and significantly impacts its characteristics. It may consist of various materials and layers, including foam, latex, micro-coils, and fabrics like cotton and wool.
To make a fair comparison between the Tuft & Needle and Casper beds, it is crucial to examine their construction from the top comfort system to the bottom support core.
All Tuft & Needle mattresses share two common elements. The cover, made with polyester and micro-polyamide, offers a breathable and soft surface for the Original, Mint, and Hybrid models.
The second common component found in all Tuft & Needle mattresses is the proprietary Adaptive Foam. This unique polyfoam blend combines the qualities of memory foam and latex.
Adaptive Foam provides mild conformity for pressure point relief, offering extra cushioning to heavier body parts. It is also highly responsive, making it easy to move on top of the mattress. Unlike traditional memory foam, it does not soften with heat and is infused with gel to combat heat retention.
Original Tuft & Needle:
The Original Tuft & Needle mattress has a simple design:
– 3 inches of Adaptive Foam
– 7 inches of high-density polyfoam
Despite its straightforward construction, the Original provides ample support and comfort for most sleepers. Its medium firm feel appeals to a wide range of individuals.
Tuft & Needle Mint:
Building upon the Original’s success, Tuft & Needle introduced the Mint, which adds an extra layer to the design:
– 3 inches of Adaptive Foam
– 2 inches of Adaptive Foam
– 7 inches of high-density polyfoam
With a two-inch thicker comfort system, the Mint offers enhanced pressure relief and durability for individuals weighing over 230 pounds. This additional thickness also helps prevent excessive sinking into the mattress. The Mint Mattress cover contains an antimicrobial protectant, safeguarding against harmful bacteria and increasing its lifespan. The top half of the cover is removable for machine washing.
Tuft & Needle Hybrid:
The Tuft & Needle Hybrid takes a different approach in its construction:
– Adaptive Foam
– Micro-coils
– Transition polyfoam
– Pocketed innerspring coils
The Hybrid provides a slightly softer feel compared to all-foam mattresses, thanks to the dual layers of coils. The coils allow for improved airflow, ensuring a cool sleeping experience throughout the night. They also enhance the edge support of the Hybrid, surpassing that of the Original and Mint models.
Tuft & Needle is known for providing a general description of the materials used in their mattresses, but they do not offer specific details or specifications. This lack of information is especially noticeable when reviewing their Hybrid mattress because the thickness of each individual layer is not publicly listed. With limited information about the construction, it becomes more challenging to thoroughly assess the quality of the mattress. However, customer reviews can provide valuable insight into its performance.
Casper, on the other hand, offers a diverse range of five different mattresses in their product line.
The first two mattresses in Casper’s lineup are the Casper Original and the Casper Hybrid.
The Casper Original and the Casper Hybrid have the same comfort system but differ in their support core.
Here is the layer organization for the Casper Original:
– 1.5 inches of polyfoam
– 2 inches of zoned memory foam
– 7 inches of polyfoam
The Casper Hybrid has the following construction:
– 1.5 inches of polyfoam
– 2 inches of zoned memory foam
– 6 inches of pocketed coils with a 7-inch foam encasement
By incorporating two different types of foam in the comfort system, both the Casper Original and the Casper Hybrid provide excellent contouring without sacrificing responsiveness. As a result, these mattresses offer above-average pressure relief and motion isolation. The Hybrid version also delivers superior edge support and bounce.
Moving on to Casper’s entry-level mattress, we have the Casper Element. This mattress is designed with simplicity in mind and includes the following layers:
– 3 inches of ventilated polyfoam
– 6.5 inches of polyfoam
Like other models from Casper, the Element provides pressure relief through the foam in its comfort layer. However, it does not feature the zoned foams found in more advanced models. It was intentionally designed as a basic, budget-friendly mattress that still offers solid value.
Next up is the Casper Wave Hybrid, which stands out for its innovative design. It consists of the following components:
– 1 inch of polyfoam
– 1.5 inches of ventilated latex
– 1.5 inches of zoned memory foam
– 1.5 inches of zoned polyfoam with built-in targeted gel pods
– 6 inches of pocketed coils with a 7-inch foam encasement
The Wave Hybrid introduces a new layer with targeted gel pods, which enhances its ability to provide zoned support that caters to individual sleepers’ needs. The combination of latex-like polyfoam, latex, and memory foam above the gel-pod layer contributes to a blend of motion isolation, bounce, and pressure relief. Despite its pronounced contouring, the Wave Hybrid effectively dissipates heat, ensuring a cool sleep environment. Its medium firmness is suitable for those weighing under 130 pounds and most side sleepers.
Finally, there is the Casper Nova Hybrid, which includes the following components:
– 1″ adaptive polyfoam
– 1.5″ zoned polyfoam
– 2″ contour-cut memory foam
– 6″ pocketed coils in a 7″ polyfoam encasement
The Nova Hybrid is Casper’s softest mattress and offers exceptional contouring for a hybrid model. The top layer of adaptive polyfoam closely hugs the body, while the second polyfoam layer is divided into three firmness zones to provide targeted support and comfortable cradling. Features such as consistent temperature neutrality and above-average motion isolation add to the appeal of this mattress, particularly for individuals who prefer a plusher feel.
Despite appearing similar at a glance, mattresses vary significantly in their construction, features, and performance. In the following section, we will delve into the essential factors influencing customer satisfaction with mattresses. By understanding these factors, you can identify your own priorities and make informed comparisons between different brands and models.
These factors include:
– Durability: Since mattresses endure prolonged use and provide support for hours every night, their durability is crucial. Poorly constructed mattresses may wear out prematurely, resulting in reduced pressure relief, bounce, and overall comfort. Additionally, a longer-lasting mattress offers a better return on investment. While most mattresses typically last around five years, well-built models can maintain their performance for several additional years.
The following tables present a comprehensive evaluation of the performance of the Tuft & Needle and Casper mattresses in these specific areas.
The pricing of mattresses can vary significantly, leading to confusion among customers who may question the wide range of prices available.
It is important to note that customers rarely pay the full retail price (MSRP), as there are nearly always discounts or promotions available to reduce the final cost.
Moreover, a higher price does not guarantee a superior mattress. While price and quality are often correlated, it is not a perfect relationship, as multiple factors can influence the MSRP of a particular mattress model. Some examples of these factors include:
- The total number of layers in the mattress
- The thickness of each individual layer
- The materials used in each layer
- Whether the mattress possesses relevant certifications, such as for organic production
- The country of origin where the mattress was manufactured
- Inclusion of special features designed for pressure relief, temperature regulation, or other performance-related elements
Fortunately for shoppers, the intense competition within the mattress industry ensures that exceptional value can be found across various budget categories.
The table below illustrates the retail prices of the Tuft & Needle and Casper mattresses in standard sizes.
Exclusive Sleep Foundation Offer
Use this SleepFoundation.org link to access the most up-to-date discount for Tuft and Needle mattresses.
Exclusive Offer from the Sleep Foundation
Readers of the Sleep Foundation can take advantage of the greatest deals on Casper products.
The range of prices within the online mattress industry is clearly illustrated by the offerings from Tuft & Needle and Casper.
The Casper Element and the Tuft & Needle Original have virtually identical price points. Both provide a budget-friendly option with a simple design consisting solely of foam.
For a slightly higher price, you will find two more substantial all-foam mattresses – the Casper Original and the Tuft & Needle Mint – which have a similar price. These 12-inch models are excellent choices in terms of overall value. Compared to the more affordable options, they feature a thicker comfort system that ensures a durable bed with more balanced performance.
Although the all-foam options are similarly priced, there is a greater disparity between the Casper Hybrid and the Tuft & Needle Hybrid. The Tuft & Needle Hybrid is more expensive, but it includes a coil-on-coil design that is particularly appealing to those who prefer the feel of innerspring coils.
Only Casper offers mattresses in the luxury category. The Nova Hybrid and Wave Hybrid are packed with features and incorporate innovative materials for support and temperature control. Unsurprisingly, these mattresses come with significantly higher price tags compared to the budget and value options from these two companies.
Regardless of which option you are considering, be sure to look for any available promotions or discounts. In most cases, you can save at least 5% off the original price.
100 Nights (30-Night Requirement)
Free Shipping to Contiguous U.S. and Canadian Provinces
A significant part of the success of brands like Casper and Tuft & Needle stems from their ability to simplify online mattress shopping for customers. This entails careful attention to the logistics of shipping, returns, and warranties.
If this is your first time purchasing a mattress online, the following sections will provide an explanation of these practicalities and what you can expect from these two leading brands.
When you order a mattress online, there are two main delivery methods: mattress-in-a-box shipping and White Glove delivery.
Efficient Matress-in-a-Box Shipping
Matress-in-a-box shipping plays a crucial role in the growth of the online mattress industry. It involves compressing the mattress, encasing it in plastic, and delivering it via FedEx or UPS ground services. The box is delivered right to your door, and once you bring it to your bedroom and remove the packaging, the mattress expands back to its full size.
This is the standard shipping method for online mattresses and is almost always offered for free. The package typically arrives within a few business days after placing the order. However, it is worth noting that it usually requires two people to move the box and set up the mattress.
Tuft & Needle provides free mattress-in-a-box shipping for all of its mattresses. Expedited mattress-in-a-box shipping is available for an additional charge.
Casper offers free standard shipping for the Casper Original, Hybrid, and Element mattresses. Expedited shipping, including same-day delivery, is available in certain locations for a fee. The Wave Hybrid includes free White Glove delivery.
Premium White Glove Delivery
White Glove delivery includes mattress installation. A team will bring the mattress to your home and set it up in your bedroom. Once they have finished, the service often includes the removal of your old mattress as well.
Casper provides free White Glove delivery for Wave Hybrid mattresses in king and California king sizes. This service is available for an additional fee for Wave Hybrid models in other sizes, as well as for other Casper mattresses.
Tuft & Needle also offers White Glove delivery services for an additional charge.
Shipping to Locations Outside the Contiguous United States
Shipping policies usually differ for Alaska, Hawaii, or other locations outside the 48 contiguous states. Delivery may not be available, and options, including White Glove delivery, may be limited. Extra charges often apply.
Both Casper and Tuft & Needle offer ground shipping but not White Glove delivery to Alaska, Hawaii, and some international locations. The additional charge is determined at checkout and can vary depending on the shipping address.
Online mattress companies generally have return policies that are much more customer-friendly than brick-and-mortar stores. These return policies, often referred to as sleep trials, allow you to use the mattress for a certain period of time and receive a refund if you are not satisfied.
Most customers find that a sleep trial is much more effective in evaluating a mattress compared to spending just a few minutes on a bed in a showroom. Online companies typically make the return process simple and straightforward.
Casper and Tuft & Needle both have hassle-free return policies. They offer a sleep trial period of 100 nights, and you are not required to keep the mattress for a minimum number of nights. If you decide to return the mattress, these companies will work with you to arrange pick-up or donation of the mattress, and there are no additional charges for return shipping or restocking.
Mattresses almost always come with a warranty included in the purchase price. A warranty provides coverage for defects in materials and craftsmanship.
It is important to note that mattress warranties do not generally cover standard wear-and-tear or accidental damage. Instead, they protect against more significant or abnormal breakdown of the product. Additionally, the warranty requires proper care, such as using the mattress on specified types of bed frames.
In the event of a defect, the warranty will specify the appropriate remedy. Typically, this means that the company may choose to repair or replace a defective mattress. A prorated warranty requires the customer to contribute to the repair or replacement costs, and the customer’s share increases depending on how long they have owned the mattress. In contrast, a non-prorated warranty provides the same coverage throughout the entire warranty term.
Tuft & Needle and Casper both offer customer-friendly warranties that are non-prorated and last for 10 years, effectively protecting customers in the rare case of a mattress defect.
