By purchasing through the links provided, we have the potential to earn a commission. The products or services advertised on this page may be offered by a company affiliated with us. For more information, click here.
Conducting thorough research on different brands and models is a crucial step in the journey of purchasing a mattress. Each mattress available in the market today is specifically designed to cater to different individuals based on factors such as body type, sleep position, and firmness preferences. It is important to dispel the misconception that a single mattress can provide universal comfort to all sleepers. In this article, we will be comparing two leading brands that specialize in memory foam models, namely Puffy and Leesa.
Puffy entered the market in 2017 and has since made a name for itself. Puffy’s flagship mattress is a 10-inch model that consists of a comfort layer made of memory foam placed over denser polyfoam transitional and base layers. Over time, Puffy has introduced two hybrid mattresses as well. The Puffy Lux Hybrid, measuring 12 inches in thickness, builds upon the flagship bed by incorporating an additional polyfoam comfort layer to provide enhanced contouring and cushioning. It also includes a pocketed coil support core. The Puffy Royal Hybrid, with a height of 14 inches, features three foam comfort layers and a zoned transition layer that offers improved support to the torso and waist. While each additional layer makes the Puffy mattresses softer, all three models maintain a medium level of firmness (5).
Leesa, on the other hand, made its debut in 2014. The flagship Leesa Original is a mixed-foam mattress that combines a polyfoam comfort layer and a memory foam transition layer over a high-density foam base. Leesa has since released three more mattresses. The Leesa Sapira Hybrid has similar polyfoam and memory foam layers, but its support core consists of pocketed coils. The Leesa Legend is a coil-on-coil hybrid, featuring a microcoil comfort layer in addition to polyfoam and memory foam components, as well as a pocketed coil base. Lastly, the Studio by Leesa is a budget-friendly memory foam model that shares a similar construction to the Puffy Mattress. The Leesa Original is considered medium in terms of firmness (5), while the other three Leesa models are categorized as medium firm (6).
Now, let us delve deeper into the details of these Puffy and Leesa mattresses, providing a comprehensive analysis of their construction, pricing, and performance for those looking to make a comparison.
We have invested considerable efforts to present you with the most suitable mattress options for your needs. Feel free to explore our comprehensive mattress guides listed below!
Price Range (Queen)
Firmness Options
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6)
Standout Features
- Impressive body-contouring and pressure relief specifically designed for side sleepers
- Exceptional motion isolation and noise-free experience
- Responsive yet cushioning mixed-foam designs
- Ideal conformity and support for individuals weighing up to 230 pounds
Types of Mattresses
Trial Period and Warranty
– 101 Nights (Sleep Trial)
– Lifetime, Limited (Warranty)
– 100 nights with a 30 night requirement (Sleep Trial)
– 10 Year, Limited (Warranty)
Customer Service
Exclusive Offer from Sleep Foundation!
Save $750 on mattresses and receive a free luxury bundle worth $600 (includes Puffy pillows, sheet set, and protector) with every mattress order. This adds up to a total savings of $1,350.
Shop Now!
Save $700 on select mattresses and get a free mattress protector.
Shop Now!
When it comes to choosing a mattress, size is often the first factor to consider. Today, mattresses are typically available in six standard sizes. These include twin, twin XL, and full sizes for single sleepers, as well as queen, king, and California king sizes for co-sleepers.
Weight is also an important consideration for mattress-in-a-box models. Since these beds are delivered directly to your doorstep, you’ll need to carry the box to the room where you plan to use the mattress. Heavier models may require more than one person.
Lastly, think about the height, or profile, that you prefer for a mattress. Some people like to sleep close to the ground on a low-profile bed (less than 10 inches), while others prefer the extra padding of a high-profile mattress (more than 12 inches). A medium profile (10 to 12 inches) is a popular choice for many sleepers.
Puffy and Leesa offer most of their mattresses in the six standard sizes. The only exception is the Leesa Legend, which is not available in a twin size. Puffy also offers a split king option. Specialty sizes like full XL or other split options are not offered by either brand. If weight is a concern, both Puffy and Leesa have models that weigh 75 pounds or less in queen size, which is considered relatively light. The Leesa Sapira Hybrid and Leesa Legend both weigh at least 100 pounds in the same size and will be more difficult to lift and carry. All Puffy models weigh less than 100 pounds in queen size, but the hybrids are noticeably heavier than the all-foam model.
In terms of mattress profiles, Puffy and Leesa offer a variety of options. The Puffy Lux Hybrid, Puffy Royal Hybrid, and Leesa Legend are all high-profile beds, providing a thicker mattress with extra padding layers. For those who prefer a medium-profile bed, the Puffy Mattress, Leesa Original, Leesa Sapira Hybrid, and Studio by Leesa will be more suitable.
When comparing mattresses, it’s important to pay attention to the materials used in each layer. The construction and material composition of a bed can impact its price, overall feel, durability, edge support, pressure relief, and other performance factors.
Now, let’s take a closer look at the layers and materials used in Puffy and Leesa mattresses.
Puffy Mattress
The flagship Puffy Mattress features a 2-inch comfort layer of their proprietary CloudComfort memory foam. This mattress has a medium firmness (rated 5) and the foam conforms closely to your body, providing a sinking, body-cradling sensation commonly associated with memory foam mattresses. The memory foam is infused with cooling gel, although we found that it still retains some body heat – a common issue with memory foam beds. A 2-inch layer of transitional polyfoam reinforces the comfort layer and prevents excessive sinking. The support core consists of high-density polyfoam, which stabilizes the entire mattress. Overall, the Puffy Mattress is 10 inches thick, making it the shortest mattress offered by Puffy.
Puffy Lux Hybrid
The Puffy Lux Hybrid is an impressive 12 inches thick. Although it maintains a medium (5) feel, this mattress provides an even plusher surface than its flagship counterpart, resulting in deeper contouring. This can be attributed to a luxurious 1.5-inch comfort layer of gel-infused CloudComfort memory foam combined with a secondary 2-inch comfort layer of adaptive polyfoam. To further enhance its comfort, the mattress also features a transitional polyfoam layer and a support core consisting of pocketed coils and high-density base foam.
Puffy Royal Hybrid
The Puffy Royal Hybrid is not only thicker but also more indulgent than the Lux Hybrid. Nevertheless, this mattress still maintains a medium (5) feel according to our measurements. The comfort layers of this extraordinary mattress consist of 1.5 inches of gel-infused memory foam, 2 inches of polyfoam, and an additional polyfoam layer that offers both extra padding and reinforced transitional support. Due to its close contouring, this mattress molds closely to your body, providing a profound sensation of cradling comfort.
The transitional layer of the Puffy Royal Hybrid has been masterfully designed with zoning, resulting in a firmer feel beneath the chest, lower back, and hips, while providing exceptional cradling support to the head, neck, shoulders, and legs. While the intention behind the zoned foam is to enhance support, some back and stomach sleepers may experience a significant sinking sensation on the Puffy Royal Hybrid due to its unparalleled contouring capabilities. In addition to its advanced design, the mattress incorporates a 6-inch pocketed coil system and a high-density base foam layer in its support core.
All Puffy mattresses come encased in covers crafted from 100% polyester. These covers are conveniently removable and can be washed in any household machine. However, Puffy recommends washing and drying the covers only every few months, as this helps to preserve the fabric and avoid unnecessary wear and tear. It is worth noting that these covers carry the prestigious OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification, which guarantees that they have been manufactured without the use of toxic chemicals and other harmful substances.
Leesa Original
The flagship Leesa Original mattress boasts a 2-inch comfort layer of low-density polyfoam, paired with a 2-inch transitional layer of low-density memory foam. When comparing the flagship Leesa mattress to the Puffy, one noticeable difference is the bounciness and support provided by the Leesa due to its polyfoam comfort layer, which is more responsive and less contouring. It is important to mention that the polyfoam comfort layer has an indentation load deflection (ILD) of 13, while the memory foam boasts an ILD of 9. These specifications indicate a rather soft feel and close contouring, as foam ILD can reach up to 40 in firmer mattresses.
The lower density of the comfort and transitional foams employed in the Leesa Original also contributes to its breathable nature, as higher-density foams tend to retain more body heat. However, it is worth noting that lower foam density is often associated with shorter mattress lifespans, which may result in impressions forming over time. Supporting the mattress is a 6-inch support core crafted from 1.8 PCF high-density polyfoam.
Leesa Sapira Hybrid
The Leesa Sapira Hybrid features two comfort layers. The top layer, 1.5 inches thick, is constructed from low-density polyfoam, while the second layer, also 1.5 inches thick, is composed of medium-density memory foam. This combination results in a medium-firm feel for the Sapira Hybrid, offering both support and durability. Additionally, the presence of a transitional polyfoam layer provides extra reinforcement to prevent excessive sinking.
The 6-inch support core of the Leesa Sapira Hybrid incorporates pocketed coils. These interior coils boast a gauge of 14.5, indicating a balanced thickness and robust support. The edges of the mattress are fortified with thicker coils to ensure minimal sinking when entering and exiting the bed. To further enhance stability, a 1-inch layer of high-density base polyfoam supports the coil layer.
Leesa Legend
Similar to the other Leesa models, the Leesa Legend is a hybrid mattress. Its top comfort layer, 1-inch thick, is made of aerated polyfoam, allowing for increased airflow near the surface, which contributes to enhanced cooling. The mattress also includes a second comfort layer, 1-inch thick, consisting of memory foam, as well as a third layer, 1.5 inches thick, of polyfoam-zoned microcoils. The memory foam on the Leesa Legend adapts closely to the body, providing a personalized contour, while the zoned microcoils offer comprehensive support throughout the entire body and create a more responsive surface. This is an ideal choice for individuals who prefer a bouncier mattress.
The Leesa Legend boasts a transitional polyfoam layer that is strategically designed to support and cradle specific areas of the body, such as the stomach and hips, where additional weight tends to accumulate. This feature makes it an ideal choice for individuals who prefer to sleep on their side or back, regardless of their weight group. The interior pocketed coils of the Leesa Legend have a 15-gauge thickness, slightly thinner than those found in the Leesa Sapira Hybrid. However, this mattress makes up for it with thicker coils that ensure stability along the perimeter.
On the other hand, the Studio by Leesa represents the latest addition to the brand’s lineup. It distinguishes itself from other Leesa mattresses by incorporating a comfort layer made entirely of memory foam. This unique feature provides a more traditional memory foam experience, characterized by deep contouring and a gradual response. The mattress derives its overall reinforcement from a transitional polyfoam layer and a high-density polyfoam support core. Those who prefer a medium firm feel will find this mattress particularly suitable, especially if they weigh 130 pounds or more.
When it comes to the cover materials, each Leesa model varies. The Leesa Original, Leesa Sapira Hybrid, and the Studio by Leesa all feature polyester-blend covers. In contrast, the Leesa Legend’s cover is crafted from a blend of fabrics, including polyester, recycled plastic, organic cotton, merino wool, rayon, and spandex. It should be noted that none of the Leesa mattress covers are removable for cleaning purposes. However, in case of stains, spot cleaning with mild detergent and cool water is recommended by the company.
Every mattress possesses distinct advantages and disadvantages, determined by factors such as firmness, profile thickness, and the materials used in its construction. Based on extensive feedback from sleepers and our own rigorous testing, we have assigned ratings to Puffy and Leesa mattresses across various performance categories.
Firstly, durability must be taken into consideration, as the average mattress requires replacement after 6 to 8 years of use. Over time, the materials in the comfort, transitional, and support layers will progressively deteriorate, resulting in a loss of shape, decreased support from the base layers, and increased sinkage when getting in and out of bed. Innerspring and all-foam mattresses generally have the shortest lifespans among all mattress types, lasting approximately six to seven years on average. On the other hand, hybrids tend to last at least six and a half years.
The ability to isolate motion is another crucial aspect. Some mattresses are specifically engineered with materials that absorb and minimize motion transfer, allowing you and your partner to move freely without disrupting each other’s sleep. However, mattresses that are more responsive due to components such as latex or coils may experience increased motion transfer, leading to potential sleep disturbances.
Furthermore, responsiveness and contouring are essential for optimal sexual experience. Most couples prefer mattresses that provide gentle contouring and responsiveness, allowing freedom of movement without excessive sinking. It is also important to consider edge support, as weak edges accompanied by deep sinkage may limit your movement to the center of the mattress.
Temperature neutrality is a paramount factor to ensure a comfortable sleep environment. Mattresses with solid foam layers tend to absorb and retain body heat, resulting in excessive warmth. Conversely, materials such as ventilated foam or latex layers, coil systems that facilitate airflow, and cooling fabrics and fibers infused in the mattress cover, promote breathability and temperature regulation. The level of firmness can also impact temperature neutrality, as deep contouring can impede surface airflow.
Pressure relief is a significant aspect, determined by both body weight and sleep position. An ideal mattress for pressure relief should provide adequate support to the lower back, cushion the heavier areas of the body without excessive sinking, and promote proper spinal alignment. Individuals weighing less than 130 pounds generally prefer softer mattresses that conform closely, while those weighing more than 230 pounds tend to gravitate towards firmer, more supportive options.
Lastly, it is worth mentioning that mattresses with foam layers often emit an initial off-gassing odor when unpacked from their shipping boxes. This smell originates from volatile organic compounds (VOCs) present in the foam. Typically, these odors dissipate within a few days. However, mattresses with denser foam layers may require additional time to air out. If the smell persists after a couple of days, placing the mattress in a well-ventilated room can help eliminate the unwanted odor.
Ease of Movement
Moving across beds that sink deeply can prove to be rather challenging; many individuals compare the sensation to being trapped in the mattress. If a bed sinks excessively, you will likely encounter difficulties when trying to get on and off the mattress, and may also experience discomfort when changing sleep positions. On the other hand, firmer and more responsive mattresses generally do not present this issue.
Edge Support
Most beds tend to sink at least a little when pressure is applied near their edges. Nevertheless, certain mattresses reinforce the perimeter by incorporating thick coils, dense foams, and other supportive materials to offer increased resistance and prevent excessive sinking. Conversely, softer mattresses with less robust edge materials will likely sink quite a bit, and this problem may worsen over time, resulting in increased instability.
Various factors contribute to the pricing of a mattress. For instance, smaller sizes typically cost a few hundred, if not several thousand, dollars less than larger sizes. Material construction also plays a crucial role.
The average price range for an all-foam mattress in a queen size falls between $900 and $1,200, while hybrid mattresses typically cost between $1,600 and $2,200 in the same size. Furthermore, certain brands simply set higher prices for their mattresses. This is particularly true for physical retailers, who face substantial overhead costs associated with operating stores and employing commissioned sales staff. Online brands, on the other hand, do not typically bear this type of overhead and can offer mattresses at much lower prices.
The current prices for each Puffy and Leesa mattress in every available size are detailed in the tables below.
Special Offer from the Sleep Foundation
Enjoy $750 off mattresses and receive a complimentary luxury bundle (worth $600, including Puffy pillows, a sheet set, and a protector) with every mattress purchase. A total saving of $1,350.
Special Offer from the Sleep Foundation
Receive a $700 discount on select mattresses and a free mattress protector.
The price of the Puffy Mattress aligns with the average cost of an all-foam model. However, the Puffy Lux Hybrid and Puffy Royal Hybrid are priced quite high. This might deter potential buyers who have a limited shopping budget.
In comparison, Leesa’s all-foam and hybrid models are in line with, if not cheaper than, the industry averages for these types of mattresses. That being said, the Leesa Sapira Hybrid and Leesa Legend still carry a somewhat steep price tag.
100 nights (30-night minimum requirement)
Both Puffy and Leesa offer free ground shipping to customers across all 50 states. Additionally, Leesa ships mattresses to Canada, the United Kingdom, and Germany, whereas Puffy’s deliveries are limited to the United States.
For standard deliveries, all Puffy and Leesa mattresses are compressed, vacuum-sealed, and shipped in a compact box. The box will be delivered to your doorstep, eliminating the need for you to sign for the package or be present at home when the mattress arrives. Simply carry the box to the desired room, unbox it, and use a knife to remove the plastic. The mattress will immediately begin expanding but allow at least 24 hours for it to fully regain its shape.
Leesa also provides White Glove delivery service in select areas for a fixed fee of $150. This service includes a scheduled delivery date, in-home assembly of the mattress, and, upon request, removal of your old mattress and/or box spring. Mattresses delivered via White Glove service are not compressed. Puffy does not offer in-home assembly or removal of old mattresses or box springs with any orders.
Given that most online mattress brands do not operate physical stores where customers can test their models, these companies typically offer sleep trials of 90 nights or longer. In most cases, you will have the opportunity to return the mattress for a full refund. Sleep trials are essential in truly understanding how a mattress feels and performs before making a financial commitment.
Puffy’s sleep trial gracefully stretches over a span of 101 nights, starting from the day of delivery. Puffy kindly requests that you thoroughly examine the mattress for a minimum of 14 nights before initiating a return or exchange. However, Puffy highly recommends spending at least 30 nights snugly curled up on the mattress to fully acquaint yourself with its exceptional comfort. In the event of a change of heart, Puffy will graciously provide a complete refund (minus shipping fees for Alaska and Hawaii) and dispatch their trusty couriers to collect the mattress from your abode, carefully transporting it for donation or recycling. Each household has the opportunity to take advantage of Puffy’s sleep trial on two separate occasions.
Leesa’s sleep trial comes in at a robust 100 nights in duration. There’s no obligatory initiation period tied to this trial, but just like Puffy, Leesa kindly suggests giving the mattress a fair chance by testing it out for at least 30 nights before pursuing a return. Leesa generously offers a complete refund for customers residing in the contiguous U.S., and their diligent couriers will promptly whisk away the mattress from your humble dwelling. For those residing in Alaska or Hawaii, a nominal return fee of $100 is applicable, but fear not, for the couriers shall still arrive to collect the mattress without any additional charge. Leesa strives to gift all returned mattresses to those in need, but should the need arise, recycling shall be gracefully embraced.
A warranty is a sacred covenant between the creator of a product and the honorable individuals who purchase it, ensuring that any defects will be attended to through repairs or replacements. The overwhelming majority of mattresses available in today’s market come with a warranty that generously spans a minimum of 10 years.
Puffy stands apart as one of the illustrious mattress brands that offers a non-proportional lifelong warranty for their esteemed mattresses. In the realm of mattresses, non-proportional means that you shall not incur any cost should your mattress encounter a defect and require repairs or replacements. The term “lifelong” signifies that the warranty shall protect your precious mattress for as long as you remain its noble guardian, and replacements are also encompassed by this benevolent arrangement. Under this extraordinary warranty, defects are defined as depressions or indentations in the surface measuring a commendable 1.5 inches or deeper, as well as imperfections tied to the mattress cover that are born out of the manufacturing process.
Leesa’s warranty, though slightly shorter at a span of 10 years, is no less magnanimous. This warranty, too, is devoid of proportionality. Therefore, should your mattress harbor a defect during the initial decade of its existence, you shall not be burdened with any costs except for modest shipping and transportation expenses required to rectify or replace the sleeping marvel. This generous warranty covers depressions and indentations measuring 1 inch or deeper, physical flaws that result in premature deterioration of materials, and manufacturing defects pertaining to the mattress cover.
It is important to note that mattress warranties are not transferable, meaning only the esteemed original purchaser is granted the privilege of basking in the soothing embrace of warranty coverage. Should you acquire or procure the mattress from anyone but the original purchaser, you shall regrettably be bereft of the comforting protection of the warranty. Therefore, it is of utmost importance to always purchase mattresses directly from the revered brands or their esteemed authorized retailers.
