If you make a purchase using the links we provide, we may receive a commission. The products or services advertised on this page may be offered by a company affiliated with us. To find out more, click here.
Casper and Amerisleep are reputable brands that have successfully built their businesses around selling mattresses online. They have even expanded their operations to include their own brick-and-mortar mattress showrooms. It comes as no surprise that many people who are in the market for a new mattress find themselves torn between Casper and Amerisleep.
Both Casper and Amerisleep offer a wide range of mattress models, giving customers the option to choose the bed that best fits their budget, desired firmness level, and support needs. However, having so many options can make it challenging for some shoppers to decide between Casper and Amerisleep.
Our comprehensive comparison presents an overview of their full range of offerings, including the Casper Original, Casper Hybrid, Casper Wave Hybrid, Casper Nova Hybrid, and the affordable Casper Element, as well as the AS1 through AS5 beds from Amerisleep. We have compared these products side-by-side, assessing their price points, performance characteristics, and unique features, while also providing information on shipping, warranties, and returns.
We have put in considerable effort to help you find the mattress that is the perfect fit for you. Take a look at our comprehensive mattress guides below!
Price Range (Queen)
Firmness Options
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6)
Soft (3), Medium Soft (4), Medium (5), Medium Firm (6), Firm (7)
Standout Features
-
An impressive selection of hybrid and all-foam options
-
A compelling combination of pressure relief and responsiveness
-
A wide price range, providing options from budget-friendly mattresses to luxury choices
-
A dedication to innovative mattress design.
Pressure relief is excellent thanks to the memory foam top layer. The foam production methods used are eco-friendly. For couples, the motion isolation is very good. The addition of zoned polyfoam provides a tailored feel to most Amerisleep models.
Sleep Trial & Warranty:
– 100 Nights (with a 30-Night Requirement)
– 10 Year, Limited Warranty
Models:
Sleep Trial & Warranty:
– 100 nights (with a 30-night requirement)
– 20 Year, Limited Warranty
Customer Service:
Exclusive Offer for Sleep Foundation Readers!
Sleep Foundation readers can get the best price on Casper products.
Shop Now!
Get $300 off any mattress at Amerisleep.
Shop Now!
There are certain practical factors that can influence your mattress shopping experience. These include the size, weight, and height of the mattress.
Choosing the right mattress size is essential to ensure that there is enough space for you and, if necessary, a bed partner, to feel comfortable. However, it is also important to consider the size of your bedroom and avoid making it feel crowded.
The height of the mattress is important for ensuring that the fitted sheet fits properly, and it can also impact how easy it is to get in and out of bed.
The weight of the mattress is most significant when it comes to moving it. While most mattresses require two or three people to move them safely, a heavy bed can still be a challenge. For those who frequently move, a lighter mattress may be preferred.
Size Options:
– Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King
Size Options:
– Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King
Size Options:
– Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Options for Sizes
A multitude of dimensions are available when it comes to the mattresses offered by Amerisleep and Casper. Their offerings are similar in terms of height, and regular fitted sheets should fit all models. Both companies provide their mattresses in the six standard sizes. However, there are a few key differences:
- Amerisleep offers a unique Split King option, while Casper customers can achieve the same result by purchasing two Twin XL mattresses.
- Casper offers both hybrid and all-foam mattresses, whereas Amerisleep exclusively offers all-foam options.
- Compared to either company’s foam options, Casper’s hybrid mattresses are significantly heavier. This is normal for hybrids, as the innerspring component adds more weight compared to foam.
Understanding how a mattress is constructed provides valuable insight into its performance and durability.
A few terms provide helpful context regarding the interior construction of mattresses. The comfort system, which can consist of multiple layers, is situated at the top of the mattress and greatly influences its feel. The support core, located at the bottom, serves as the foundation for the mattress.
A hybrid mattress features a support core made of coils and a thick comfort system above it, which can incorporate various types of materials. On the other hand, an all-foam mattress has a polyfoam support core and a comfort system that utilizes different materials.
Both Casper and Amerisleep mattresses demonstrate meticulous design, which becomes evident when examining the construction of their respective products.
Casper offers a total of five mattress options. Two of these are all-foam mattresses, while three are hybrids. All mattresses share the same cover, comprised of a blend of polyester made from recycled plastics, regular polyester, upcycled cotton, rayon, and spandex. This combination of materials makes the cover stretchable, breathable, and eco-friendly, helping to reduce the number of plastic bottles ending up in landfills.
Casper Original & Casper Hybrid
As the name suggests, the Casper Original was the first mattress introduced by the company. It features an all-foam design with three interior layers:
- 1.5 inches of specialty polyfoam
- 2 inches of memory foam with three zones
- 7 inches of base polyfoam
The Casper Hybrid is an adaptation of the successful Casper Original. The top three layers, known as the comfort system, remain the same, but the support core differs. Overall, the Casper Hybrid consists of three layers:
- 1.5 inches of specialty polyfoam
- 2 inches of memory foam with three zones
- 7 inches of pocketed coils with foam encasing them
Both mattresses incorporate a combination of two distinct foams in the comfort system, providing a balance between contouring and responsiveness. The Casper Hybrid enhances the bounce with its innerspring coils, and its edge support is reinforced by the coils and high-density foam encasement. The Casper Original and Casper Hybrid both have a medium (5) firmness level.
Casper Nova Hybrid
Introducing the latest addition to Casper’s mattress collection, the Casper Nova Hybrid. This innovative mattress features a unique composition of four internal layers:
- 1 inch of AirScape polyfoam
- 1.5 inches of 3-zoned AirScape polyfoam
- 2 inches of 7-zoned memory foam
- 7 inches of pocketed coils with a perimeter foam encasement
The Casper Nova Hybrid offers a plush, yet supportive feel with a medium (5) firmness level. The AirScape polyfoam in this model is designed to provide breathability and softness without compromising responsiveness. The zoned foams work together to reinforce the mattress under heavier areas of the body, while the memory foam enhances contouring and pressure relief for the ultimate comfort experience.
Casper Wave Hybrid
For those seeking luxury and innovation, the Casper Wave Hybrid is the perfect choice. This high-end mattress incorporates several design advancements developed by Casper’s product development team. It consists of five layers:
- 1 inch of AirScape polyfoam
- 1.5 inches of AirScape polyfoam
- 1.5 inches of 3-zoned AirScape foam
- 1.5 inches of zoned polyfoam with targeted gel pods
- 7 inches of pocketed coils with a perimeter foam encasement
The Wave Hybrid utilizes Casper’s proprietary AirScape polyfoam in the top three layers. The third layer features a zoned AirScape formulation for enhanced comfort and support in the midsection. Additionally, the polyfoam with targeted gel pods allows the mattress to adapt to each sleeper’s weight distribution, providing a personalized feel. The thick coil layer with perimeter encasement ensures stability, bounce, and edge support. With a medium (5) feel, the Wave Hybrid guarantees a premium level of comfort.
Casper Element
For those seeking affordability without compromising quality, the Casper Element is the ideal choice. This all-foam mattress offers a firm feel, rating as medium firm (6) in firmness. It features a simple yet effective design with two layers:
- 3 inches of AirScape polyfoam
- 6.5 inches of base polyfoam
Although it lacks the advanced features of other Casper models, the Element provides a reliable entry-level mattress that offers excellent pressure point relief without excessive sinking.
Amerisleep offers a range of five all-foam mattresses, all constructed with similar materials. The main distinction among these options lies in the thickness of the interior layers and the firmness level.
All Amerisleep mattresses share certain components, including:
- Cotton-blend cover: Amerisleep mattress covers are made from a breathable blend of cotton and polyester, ensuring a cool sleeping surface.
- Bio-foams: Amerisleep utilizes plant-based oils in the creation of their foams, reducing the carbon footprint compared to traditional foam production methods. The Bio-Pur memory foam and Bio-Core base polyfoam have a density of 4 pounds per cubic foot (PCF), making them durable and environmentally friendly.
- Surface Modification Technology (SMT): Amerisleep’s unique HIVE polyfoam design incorporates five zones that offer targeted support to different areas of the body.
The AS1 is Amerisleep’s firmest mattress option, featuring the thinnest comfort system. With a firm (7) feel, it consists of two interior layers:
- 2 inches of Bio-Pur memory foam
- 8 inches of Bio-Core base polyfoam
The AS2 offers a medium-firm (6) feel and three layers:
- 2 inches of Bio-Pur memory foam
- 3 inches of 5-zoned SMT polyfoam
- 7 inches of Bio-Core base polyfoam
With the addition of the SMT polyfoam, the AS2 provides enhanced customization to the body compared to the AS1.
Lastly, the AS3 offers a medium (5) feel and three interior components:
Three inches of Bio-Pur memory foam, followed by two inches of 5-zoned SMT polyfoam, and then seven inches of Bio-Core base polyfoam make up the AS3 mattress.
The AS4 mattress, on the other hand, consists of four inches of Bio-Pur memory foam, one inch of 5-zoned SMT polyfoam, and seven inches of Bio-Core base polyfoam. This particular mattress stands out due to its thick memory foam layer, allowing for exceptional motion isolation and deep contouring.
For a soft feel, the AS5 mattress combines three inches of Bio-Pur memory foam, two inches of ActiveFlex polyfoam, two inches of 5-zoned SMT polyfoam, and seven inches of Bio-Core base polyfoam. Additionally, the AS5 boasts a layer of ActiveFlex polyfoam, providing a latex-like sensation and increased responsiveness compared to other Amerisleep models.
In all Amerisleep mattresses, the top layer of Bio-Pur memory foam offers remarkable pressure relief and effective motion isolation. The base polyfoam provides a sturdy feel while enhancing the overall performance of the comfort system.
Differentiating between mattresses can be challenging due to the abundance of technical jargon and marketing hype. However, by delving into the specifics of construction and considering customer reviews, you can better evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of each mattress. Evaluating key features and performance characteristics will assist you in finding the ideal mattress to meet your needs.
When selecting a mattress, durability is crucial. Look for mattresses with thoughtful design, high-quality materials, and meticulous construction to ensure longevity. For individuals placing additional strain on their mattress, such as those weighing over 230 pounds or with pronounced pressure points, a thicker comfort system can contribute to the mattress’s durability.
Motion isolation is important for bed-sharing individuals. A mattress with excellent motion isolation minimizes vibrations across the bed, allowing for uninterrupted sleep. Memory foam is renowned for its superior motion isolation abilities.
Consider the impact of the mattress on sexual activity as well. Shoppers with an active sex life should opt for a mattress that provides sufficient bounce and quick response to weight adjustments. Materials such as coils, latex, and latex-like foams facilitate sexual activity better than other options.
Temperature neutrality is another vital factor to consider. If a mattress traps heat or restricts airflow, sleepers may wake up overheated and sweaty. Design elements incorporated into the cover, comfort system, and support core can enhance temperature neutrality.
Pressure relief is essential for pain-free sleep. A mattress should support the body and provide adequate cushioning for pressure points, ensuring proper spinal alignment. Various foam materials, especially memory foam, excel at relieving pressure and contouring to the body.
Most mattresses have a temporary “new mattress smell” due to volatile organic compounds (VOCs) released during the manufacturing process. While these VOCs are not harmful, they can cause discomfort, particularly for individuals with allergies or sensitivity to odors. Foam mattresses tend to have more off-gassing issues compared to other types of mattresses.
- Freedom of Movement: Some mattresses can make you feel trapped or engulfed, hindering your ability to move freely. While certain individuals may enjoy this sensation, it can impede your movements when getting out of bed, changing sleeping positions, or engaging in intimate activities. Mattresses that offer more bounce and less pronounced sinking tend to allow for smoother movement.
- Edge Support: To fully utilize the entire surface of your mattress, you need edge-to-edge stability. Poor edge support can make it feel like you’re going to be thrown off the bed when sleeping near the edges. Sitting on the edge may also give you a sense of instability. All-foam beds generally have weaker edge support due to the compression of the foam, while hybrids are typically sturdier around the perimeter.
No mattress excels in all these categories. For instance, prioritizing deep contouring and pressure relief can potentially lead to issues with temperature neutrality or ease of movement. Therefore, each shopper should consider their own needs and select the mattress that aligns best with them. To facilitate this process, we provide a breakdown of the ratings for each Casper and Amerisleep model below.
Investing in a mattress is a significant decision, and it’s expected that a high-quality mattress will come with a higher price tag compared to a poorly made one. However, a glimpse into the world of mattress options reveals a vast range of prices. Several factors impact mattress pricing, including:
- The choice of materials
- The thickness of the layers/materials
- The total number of layers
- Special features (such as cooling, cleaning, or recovery properties)
- Specialty materials (such as organic or eco-friendly options)
- The place of manufacture
Both Casper and Amerisleep offer mattresses at various price points, ensuring there are compelling options for almost any budget. The prices for each model, categorized by size, are provided below. Note that these are retail (MSRP) prices, and promotions and discounts are typically available to lower the final cost.
Exclusive Deal for Sleep Foundation Readers
Get the best price on Casper products.
Exclusive Deal for Sleep Foundation Readers
Get $300 off any mattress from Amerisleep
Casper provides more choices for budget-conscious shoppers than Amerisleep, as both the Casper Element and Casper Original are priced lower than the least expensive AS1 from Amerisleep. The Element, in particular, is the most accessible option for those on a tight budget.
Among the two companies, the most expensive choice is the Casper Wave Hybrid, which carries a higher price tag than Amerisleep’s AS5. Casper’s Nova Hybrid is also nearly as costly as the AS5.
Overall, both companies offer quality mattress options across a wide price range, and they frequently offer coupons or discounts to help savvy shoppers make the most of a mattress sale.
100 Nights (30-Night Minimum)
Free Shipping to Contiguous U.S. and Canadian Provinces
100 nights (30-night minimum)
Casper and Amerisleep have earned strong reputations for their customer service, and a part of that stems from their approach to shipping, returns, and warranty concerns. For first-time online mattress buyers, knowledge of these aspects can ensure a seamless mattress purchasing experience.
Typically, online mattresses are delivered in a convenient mattress-in-a-box format. This involves compressing the mattress tightly into plastic packaging, placing it in a cardboard box, and shipping it to your doorstep via ground shipping services. No assembly is required; you simply need to bring the box into your bedroom and remove the packaging for the mattress to expand to its full size. It is recommended to have two individuals work together to safely lift and set up the mattress.
Advanced delivery services are available that include a team of skilled technicians who will come to your home and set up your mattress for you. As part of this exceptional White-Glove delivery service, they will also take away your old mattress.
Shipping Policies by Casper
Casper offers free standard shipping within the contiguous 48 U.S. states and Canada. There is an additional cost for shipping to other locations, such as Alaska, Hawaii, and select international destinations. Orders within the contiguous U.S. generally arrive within 5 business days, and expedited delivery may be available in certain areas.
Casper also provides an In-Home Delivery and Setup service for a fee of $149. This service includes the installation of your chosen Casper model and the removal of your old mattress.
Shipping Policies by Amerisleep
Amerisleep offers free standard shipping through FedEx for orders within the contiguous United States. These deliveries typically arrive within 5-7 business days. Shipping to Alaska, Hawaii, and other countries is available for an additional fee. Customers in those areas should contact Amerisleep directly for a shipping price quote.
Amerisleep only offers White-Glove delivery for customers who purchase a bed base.
Sleep Trial and Return Policies
Online mattress companies offer sleep trials to allow customers to try out their mattresses. During this trial period, customers can use the mattress and, if they are dissatisfied, return it for a refund. Some companies require a specific break-in period before a return can be requested, as it takes time to adjust to a new mattress. Most mattress companies arrange for free pickup of returned mattresses, although some may ask the customer to coordinate local donation or, in rare cases, pay for return delivery.
Sleep Trial and Return Policy by Casper
Casper mattresses come with a 100-night sleep trial that does not require a break-in period. Customers can request a return at any point within 100 nights after delivery, and Casper will arrange for the pickup of the mattress. A full refund will be provided once the mattress is returned, excluding charges for In-Home Delivery and Setup.
Sleep Trial and Return Policy by Amerisleep
Amerisleep offers a 100-night trial for all their mattresses. However, they require a 30-night try-out period before customers can request a return. Should you decide to return an Amerisleep mattress, the company will pick it up at no cost and provide a full refund.
A warranty is in place to cover any major, unexpected flaws in your mattress. It is important to note that a warranty does not cover normal wear-and-tear or accidental damage. Each warranty has a specific duration and a defined course of action in case of a defect.
Warranty for Casper Mattresses
Casper mattresses are protected by a 10-year warranty. If a defect occurs, Casper will repair or replace the mattress free of charge, including any associated shipping costs.
Warranty for Amerisleep Mattresses
Amerisleep offers a 20-year warranty that covers defects in materials and manufacturing. During the first 10 years, Amerisleep will repair or replace a defective mattress at no cost. From years 11 to 20, the customer will be responsible for paying 50% of the original price, as well as shipping charges, for a replacement mattress.
