By purchasing through our provided links, it is possible for us to earn a commission. It should be noted that the products or services advertised on this page may be offered by an affiliate. If you wish to learn more, please click here.
Are you struggling to choose between Lull and Casper? The vast array of products available can make it challenging to determine which mattress is best suited to your needs. However, fear not! We are here to assist you. Our review provides an unbiased examination of both brands, ensuring that you can make an informed decision without overspending.
Both brands produce mattresses of excellent quality at an affordable price. Casper offers two all-foam options: the renowned Casper Original and the budget-friendly Element. These mattresses consist of comfort layers made from polyfoam and/or memory foam, along with high-density polyfoam support cores. In addition, the brand offers three hybrid models: the Casper Hybrid, Nova Hybrid, and Wave Hybrid. Casper’s hybrid options consist of foam comfort and transitional layers, along with support cores made of pocketed coils.
Lull’s signature model is specifically designed for individuals experiencing aches and pains. It incorporates three foam layers to alleviate pressure and properly align the spine. The Lull mattress, which is reasonably priced, can be used with various bases and foundations, including box springs and adjustable beds. Additionally, the company holds several sustainability certifications and is a member of the Sustainable Furnishing Council and the Mattress Recycling Council.
Curious to discover more about the advantages of a Lull mattress versus a Casper? Continue reading to find out which mattress best suits your budget and sleep style.
We have exerted considerable effort to present you with the optimal mattress options. Please refer to the comprehensive mattress guides listed below for more information!
Price Range (Queen)
Firmness Options
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6)
Key Features
-
A wide range of product choices
-
Foam layers that absorb motion and minimize disturbances for couples
-
Most models include zoned foam for enhanced spinal alignment
-
Cooling gel-infused memory foam top layer
-
This product contains exclusive high-resilience foam.
-
It is certified by the Sustainable Furnishing Council.
Models
Sleep Trial & Warranty
-
100 Nights (Requirement of 30 Nights)
-
10 Year, Limited Warranty
-
365 Nights Sleep Trial
-
Lifetime, Limited Warranty
Customer Service
Exclusive Offer for Sleep Foundation Readers!
Get the best price on Casper products as a Sleep Foundation reader.
Shop Now
The Lull Original is now discounted by $400! No code required.
Shop Now
When choosing the size of your new mattress, there are several factors to consider. The most important one is who will be using the mattress. If you share a bed with a partner, it is important to take their preferred sleeping position into account and see how it aligns with your own. Additionally, consider if you often have pets sleeping in your bed.
Body type is another important consideration. Taller individuals, restless sleepers, and couples who are both heavier may require larger mattresses. However, a California king size may be too large for a solo sleeper or a child. Moreover, an excessively tall mattress may not be the most suitable option for children or individuals with limited mobility.
Size Options
Choose from Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King options.
Both Casper and Lull offer a wide range of sizes for all their models, including twin XL and California king options. However, Casper has a product line that includes hybrid and all-foam models, while Lull offers only an all-foam product. Casper’s hybrid models, due to their coil-based support cores, are generally heavier than their flagship foam-based model, Element, or the Lull mattress. The Wave Hybrid from Casper also features gel pads for zoned lumbar support, adding extra weight.
With a height of 13 inches, the Casper Wave Hybrid is noticeably taller than the other models in our comparison. For customers looking for a mattress for a child’s bed, the shorter and lighter Lull or the Casper Element might be more suitable. Additionally, individuals who have difficulty getting in and out of bed might find the Lull, which is only 10 inches tall but provides targeted support at pressure points, to be a better choice.
The firmness, longevity, and overall tactile experience of a mattress are heavily influenced by its construction. Different body types and sleep styles may benefit more from hybrid mattresses, while others may find all-foam mattresses more suitable. However, the differences between products go beyond their basic structure, and so do their advantages and disadvantages. For instance, hybrid models generally offer better temperature regulation than all-foam mattresses, but individuals who sleep hot may still find hybrids that incorporate cooling gel in the comfort layer to be the most preferable option.
Moreover, certain mattress types are more durable than others, and the quality of the materials used can significantly impact their lifespan. Memory foam, in particular, is notorious for sagging over time. Therefore, it is advisable to conduct research on the materials utilized in the mattress prior to making a purchase. Where do they originate from? Are they associated with any environmental or industry certifications? What insights do customer reviews provide regarding the durability of a particular model?
The Casper Original is an all-foam mattress that features three targeted zones to promote appropriate spinal alignment. Beneath a cover made from a blend of knit polyester, a layer of perforated AirScape foam specifically targets pressure points. Softer foam cradles the shoulders and upper lumbar region, while a 2-inch transitional layer of zoned memory foam provides support and reduces pressure on the hips and lower back. Supporting the entire structure is a 7-inch high-density polyfoam base that provides long-lasting stability, warding off any sagging issues. Furthermore, the cover of the bed incorporates material derived from up to 57 recycled plastic bottles.
While the Casper Hybrid has a construction that is almost identical to the Original, it differentiates itself through the utilization of a support core composed of a 7-inch layer of pocketed coils encased in polyfoam. This composition facilitates enhanced airflow, bounce, and stronger edge support.
Another foam mattress, the Element, possesses a cover crafted from a blend of recycled polyester and features a simple two-layer structure. It includes 3 inches of AirScape open-cell polyfoam and a 6.5-inch high-density polyfoam base that delivers robust support.
Although Casper’s Wave Hybrid and Nova Hybrid share similarities, they vary in terms of construction and target audience. The Nova Hybrid, ideal for individuals who prefer a softer sleep surface, displays a supple, plush quilted cover made partly from recycled plastic bottles. Its comfort system consists of a 1-inch layer of soft open-cell AirScape polyfoam, followed by an additional 1.5-inch layer of zoned AirScape polyfoam, and a 2-inch transitional memory foam layer that incorporates seven targeted zones for optimal support. Similar to other Casper hybrids, the Nova contains a support core composed of 6-inch pocketed coils reinforced by a 7-inch foam encasement.
The cover of the Wave Hybrid, which also incorporates recycled plastic bottles, utilizes up to 121 of these containers. As with the Nova Hybrid, it incorporates AirScape polyfoam and pocketed springs encased within dense foam. However, the Wave Hybrid caters to hot sleepers and individuals experiencing discomfort, necessitating additional support and reduced contouring. The top comfort layer of the mattress consists of 1 inch of open-cell AirScape polyfoam, laminated with cooling gel. The comfort system also includes a 1.5-inch layer of latex, a 1.5-inch memory foam layer with three specific zones, and 1.5 inches of zoned polyfoam containing targeted gel pods for pressure relief.
Lull’s flagship model boasts a cooling cover created from a combination of polyester and rayon fibers. Beneath the cover lies a 1.5-inch comfort layer infused with cooling gel. The transitional layer, measuring 1.5 inches, is made from conventional blended foam designed to emulate the feel of latex and prevent excessive sinking into the 7-inch polyurethane foam support core.
The Lull mattress is certified by CertiPUR-US. This certification guarantees that the mattress does not contain harmful chemicals such as formaldehyde, heavy metals, or ozone depleters. It also ensures minimal off-gassing, promoting a healthier sleep environment.
While many mattress shoppers tend to prioritize attributes such as firmness level and pressure relief, there exists a wide array of criteria that can influence customer satisfaction, and some features may hold greater importance for specific individuals. For example, budget-conscious shoppers often prioritize durability, whereas light sleepers may be more interested in mattresses that excel in motion isolation. In this section, we explore several crucial factors to keep in mind when shopping for a mattress.
- Durability: The most durable mattress is not necessarily the most expensive option, as certain models and materials have longer lifespans than others. High-quality components play a vital role in ensuring the longevity of a mattress. Typically, mattresses that incorporate steel coils or high-density foam withstand the test of time better than lightweight, all-foam models. Customers who value durability should also consider their choice of foundation for the mattress, as an unsuitable box spring or base can accelerate damage.
- Motion Separation: Motion separation is crucial for individuals who share their bed with a partner or pets, especially those who are sensitive sleepers. Certain mattresses excel at absorbing movement and preventing it from spreading across the surface, ensuring that one sleeper remains undisturbed when the other shifts or gets up. Memory foam options often excel in motion separation compared to hybrid or innerspring mattresses.
- Intimacy: Numerous couples desire a mattress that caters to both restful sleep and passionate encounters. While each couple has different preferences, most seek a responsive sleep surface that strikes a balance between softness and support. Excessively soft mattresses that contour too much can hinder freedom of movement. Additionally, some models with coil-based support systems may produce noise and lack discretion.
- Thermal Neutrality: Sleepers who tend to overheat seek breathable mattresses that remain cool throughout the night. Certain mattresses retain more heat than others, with temperature neutrality primarily dependent on the materials used. Memory foam has a tendency to trap heat and cling to the body, whereas materials like gel foam, latex, and cotton disperse body heat and enhance breathability. Coil support systems can also promote airflow.
- Relief from Pressure: Athletes, side sleepers, and individuals dealing with aches and pains benefit from mattresses that offer above-average pressure relief. Extremely firm mattresses can exacerbate discomfort by causing pressure to accumulate in areas like the shoulders and hips. Conversely, softer sleep surfaces that contour to the body provide a soothing and cradling effect on these regions. Many mattresses also incorporate zoned coil systems to target pressure points.
- Initial Odor: When unboxing a mattress, there is often an unpleasant chemical smell referred to as off-gassing. Most mattresses emit some level of odor due to volatile organic compounds (VOCs) commonly found in materials like memory foam. Although the smell usually dissipates within a couple of hours, some mattresses retain it for extended periods. If you have smell sensitivity or allergies, it is advisable to choose models with minimal off-gassing.
- Ease of Movement: Mattresses that provide above-average ease of movement allow individuals to shift positions effortlessly without sinking into the sleep surface. All-foam mattresses and heavily contoured models tend to restrict motion, whereas firmer, more responsive mattresses offer improved ease of movement.
- Edge Support: A mattress with robust edge support prevents sleepers from sinking or rolling off the edges. Excellent edge support also increases the usable sleep surface by several inches. Certain models, such as hybrids and innersprings, incorporate reinforced perimeters to strengthen the edges. On the other hand, plush foam mattresses typically offer less edge support.
While the highest-priced mattress is not always the best, it is often reflective of quality. Premium materials may come with a higher cost, but they generally result in a more durable product. Price is also influenced by the construction of the mattress. As shown in the following tables, hybrid models tend to be pricier due to their use of heavier and more diverse materials. All-foam mattresses typically feature simpler construction with fewer materials.
There are various other factors that can affect mattress pricing, including size. A king-size mattress will almost always be more expensive than a twin-size version of the same model.
Exclusive Offer from the Sleep Foundation
Readers of the Sleep Foundation can get the best price on Casper products.
Exclusive Offer from the Sleep Foundation
Get $400 off the Lull Original! No code needed
Casper offers a wide range of price points, with the budget-friendly Element at one end and the luxury Wave Hybrid as their highest-priced model. Despite its higher price tag, the Wave Hybrid provides numerous features that benefit hot sleepers and individuals dealing with aches and pains. With zoned gel pad support, targeted coils, and three layers of the company’s breathable and perforated AirScape foam, as well as cooling gel, this model stands out. In contrast, both the Casper Original and Casper Hybrid only feature a single layer of AirScape foam.
At a similar price to the Casper Original, the Lull offers substantial pressure relief while maintaining a competitive price. Unlike Casper’s flagship model, the Lull incorporates cooling gel-infused memory foam and a breathable cover, making it an ideal choice for hot sleepers. In addition, some sizes of the Lull are less expensive than their Casper Original counterparts, making it a favorable option for individuals prioritizing size.
100 Nights (Minimum of 30 Nights)
Available for Free Shipping to Contiguous United States and Canadian Provinces
The process of purchasing a mattress online differs significantly from buying one in a physical store. Although it offers convenience and comfort to many, there are additional factors to consider when purchasing a mattress on the internet. Let’s explore some of these factors below.
Shipping Arrangements
Both Casper and Lull provide free shipping services to customers in the contiguous United States. Additionally, Casper offers free shipping to customers in Canada too.
Return Policy
During the 100-night sleep trial period, Casper allows customers to return the mattress for a full refund. The return process can be initiated through the company’s official website. Casper will then arrange for a nearby charity or recycling center to collect the unwanted mattress at a time and date designated by the customer. Refunds are usually processed within two weeks.
Lull, on the other hand, offers an extensive 365-night sleep trial for their flagship mattress. This trial period is one of the longest in the online mattress industry. If customers are dissatisfied with their purchase during this time, they can return the mattress and receive a full refund. Lull provides free courier services to pick up and remove the unwanted mattress from the customer’s location.
Warranty Coverage
A mattress warranty is a written assurance from a company guaranteeing the repair or replacement of a damaged or defective product, free of charge or at a reduced cost, within a specific timeframe. Most mattress warranties have limitations, meaning they only cover certain defects, damages, or parts. For example, some warranties may solely apply to manufacturing defects or missing components. In certain cases, a mattress warranty may be dependent on the proper use of a specific foundation or bed frame.
Casper offers 10-year limited warranties for mattresses purchased directly from the company or authorized distributors. This warranty covers visible indentations larger than one inch, zipper defects, and fabric defects that are not a result of improper use. Proper use entails pairing the mattress with an appropriate foundation or frame. Casper’s warranty does not cover personal comfort preferences, second-hand mattresses, or mattresses sold “as-is”.
Lull, on the other hand, provides a lifetime warranty for their mattresses. This warranty remains valid as long as the original owner retains possession of the mattress. It covers visible indentations longer than one inch, fabric and zipper defects that occur with proper use. However, minor cosmetic flaws, normal wear and tear, stains or damages caused by the owner, personal preferences, as well as allergies, sensitivities, and off-gassing are not covered. In the first 10 years of ownership, Lull offers defect repair or replacement with no additional cost. After the initial 10 years, owners will be required to pay a flat fee of $75 if their mattress develops a defect and needs to be replaced.
-
