When you make a purchase using the links we provide, we may receive a commission. The products or services that are advertised on this page may be offered by a company affiliated with us. If you want to learn more about this, click here.
A crucial part of the process of buying a brand new mattress is narrowing down your options to a manageable number. It becomes even more useful when you’re able to choose between just two brands. If you have decided that those two brands are Nectar and Casper, then you are smartly selecting between two high-quality companies that offer a range of enticing products.
Nectar’s collection of three mattresses represents a new era for memory foam. These mattresses are capable of providing the benefits of pressure relief and motion isolation without the usual drawbacks of traditional memory foam. On the other hand, Casper offers five different mattresses in their product lineup, all featuring the exceptional performance of Airscape polyfoam that has been specially formulated by the company.
There are many appealing aspects to both the Nectar and Casper mattresses, but your personal situation and sleep needs will determine which one is more suitable for you. To assist you in making a decision, our comprehensive comparison pits Nectar against Casper. We analyze their sizes, prices, construction, performance, reviews, and more to empower you with the information you need to select the best option that will provide you with the deep sleep you desire.
We have put in a great deal of effort to help you find the perfect mattress for your needs. Take a look at our comprehensive mattress guides listed below!
Price Range (Queen):
Firmness Options:
Medium (5), Medium Firm (6)
Notable Features:
– Comfort systems that include thick layers of memory foam for excellent pressure relief and motion isolation.
– Breathable covers that wick away moisture and feel smooth to the touch.
– Long-term sleep trial of 365 nights, plus a lifetime warranty.
– A diverse product lineup that offers customers a wide range of choices across various mattress types and price points.
– Specialty Airscape polyfoam that combines contouring and responsiveness.
– Mattress cover made from recycled plastics to help reduce environmental contamination.
– Zoned materials that enhance the tailor-made cushioning of the body.
Models
Trial Period and Warranty
– 365 nights (no minimum requirement)
– Lifetime Limited Warranty
– 100 Nights (30-Night Minimum Requirement)
– 10-Year Limited Warranty
Customer Service
Exclusive Offer for Sleep Foundation Readers!
– Enjoy a 33% discount on all products.
Shop Now
– Sleep Foundation readers receive the best price on Casper products.
Shop Now
The size of a mattress can have a significant impact on your mattress purchase in several ways.
– Choosing the right mattress size ensures comfortable sleep without overcrowding your bedroom, especially for couples who generally need a full-size mattress or larger.
– Extra-tall mattresses may require special fitted sheets with deep pockets. Additionally, the height of the mattress can affect the ease of getting in and out of bed, which is relevant for individuals with arthritis or other knee, hip, or back pain.
– The weight of a mattress is mainly important when moving to a new home or when repositioning it within your bedroom.
Size Options
– Available sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King
Nectar and Casper offer all of their mattresses in the standard six mattress sizes, so there is no differentiation in this aspect between the two brands.
Regarding height, all of these mattresses fall within a range of 10 to 14 inches. The tallest options are the Nectar Premier (13 inches), Casper Wave Hybrid (13 inches), and Nectar Premier Copper (14 inches). While deep-pocket fitted sheets may be required for these models, standard sheets should work well with other Nectar and Casper mattresses.
The Casper Wave Hybrid and Casper Hybrid are the heaviest mattresses available. This is expected as hybrids generally weigh more. Among the all-foam options, the Nectar Premier is the heaviest, while the Casper Element is the lightest.
When it comes to sizing and dimensions, there aren’t major differences between Casper and Nectar. For most shoppers, these factors won’t be the deciding factors in choosing between the two brands.
To truly understand a mattress’s performance, it’s important to closely examine its components. The construction of a mattress is a strong indicator of comfort, support, and durability.
Nectar Sleep offers all-foam mattresses, each with a medium firm (6) feel and similar interior components. However, there are notable differences between the three models.
The Nectar Mattress is the company’s flagship product. It has a medium firm (6) feel and consists of four layers:
– 2 inches of gel-infused memory foam
– 3 inches of transitional polyfoam
– 7 inches of base polyfoam
The mattress provides exceptional pressure relief and motion isolation due to its thick memory foam layer. The gel infusion helps regulate temperature, while the transitional foam adds responsiveness.
The Nectar Premier is a taller version of the original mattress. It features:
– 3 inches of gel-infused memory foam with phase-change material
– 3 inches of transitional polyfoam
– 7 inches of base polyfoam
Like the Nectar Mattress, the Premier offers pressure point relief, proper spinal alignment, and motion isolation. The gel-infused memory foam and phase-change material help dissipate heat, and the transitional polyfoam provides a bouncier feel. The polyfoam support core ensures stability and support.
The Nectar Premier Copper is the tallest mattress from Nectar, measuring 14 inches. Its layers include:
– 4 inches of gel-infused memory foam with phase-change material
– 1 inch of transitional polyfoam
– 9 inches of base polyfoam
The additional thickness of the comfort layer offers closer body-contouring. The extra-tall base layer maintains a medium firm feel, with minimal sinking for individuals weighing 230 pounds or less. The copper-infused cover enhances breathability.
Casper has been a trailblazer in the mattress industry, known for selling mattresses in boxes online. The company has expanded its product line and now offers five different mattresses. However, there are similarities among all the models.
Casper’s contributions have shaped the expectations of quality, convenience, and value in online mattress shopping.
While each Casper mattress is distinct, we’ll first highlight what they have in common.
The Cover:
The fabric blend used to make the covers for all five Casper mattresses consists of a combination of polyester, upcycled cotton, polyester made from recycled plastic, rayon, and spandex. Notably, the polyester made from recycled plastic plays a crucial role in reducing the number of plastic bottles in landfills and the environment. For each Casper Original mattress, up to 57 bottles are repurposed to create the cover. In the case of the Nova mattress, up to 70 bottles are used, and for the Wave Hybrid mattress, up to 121 bottles are utilized. Moreover, aside from its eco-friendly nature, the cover is luxuriously soft, sleek, and breathable.
Airscape Foam:
Casper has developed a unique polyfoam called Airscape foam, which is designed with numerous small holes to enhance airflow and maintain a cool sleeping experience throughout the night. Functionally, the foam strikes a balance between the properties of memory foam and latex. It provides moderate contouring to relieve pressure points while still offering enough bounce to prevent sleepers from sinking too deeply into the mattress or feeling trapped in one place. While Airscape foam is present in all Casper beds, its thickness and precise composition vary depending on the specific mattress model.
Casper Original & Casper Hybrid:
The Casper Original mattress, which was the flagship product that propelled the company’s success, remains a best-seller in the online mattress market. It features a medium firmness level (5) and an all-foam construction consisting of three layers:
- 1.5 inches of Airscape polyfoam
- 2 inches of 3-zoned memory foam
- 7 inches of base polyfoam
The combination of Airscape foam and memory foam effectively supports and cushions pressure points without causing excessive sinkage or instability. The zoned construction of the memory foam further enhances its ability to contour to heavier body parts like the shoulders and hips.
The Casper Hybrid mattress shares the same comfort system design as the Casper Original, but it incorporates a support core consisting of coils:
- 1.5 inches of Airscape polyfoam
- 2 inches of 3-zoned memory foam
- 7-inch foam encasement surrounding 6 inches of pocketed coils
While also maintaining a medium firmness level (5), the Casper Hybrid provides increased bounce and additional edge support due to its coil-based support core. Like the Casper Original, sleepers on the Casper Hybrid can expect reliable pressure relief and minimal motion transfer thanks to the design of the comfort system.
Casper Nova Hybrid:
Despite their position as a prominent online mattress brand, Casper continues to invest in product development, resulting in the creation of the Casper Nova Hybrid mattress. This newer model offers a medium firmness (5) and features four interior components:
- 1 inch of Airscape polyfoam
- 1.5 inches of 3-zoned Airscape polyfoam
- 2 inches of 7-zoned memory foam
- 7-inch foam encasement surrounding 6 inches of pocketed coils
The combination of these three foam layers in the comfort system of the Nova Hybrid ensures that every part of the body receives the necessary cushioning. The mattress provides a softer feel compared to other models without the sensation of sinking into quicksand. Additionally, the foam-encased coils promote responsiveness and edge-to-edge stability.
Casper Wave Hybrid:
Casper aims to cater to a wide range of customers, including luxury shoppers, which led to the creation of the Casper Wave Hybrid mattress. With a medium firmness (5), this mattress is composed of five layers:
- 1 inch of perforated polyfoam
- A 1.5-inch layer of perforated latex
- A 1.5-inch layer of 3-zone perforated memory foam
- A 1.5-inch layer of zoned polyfoam with targeted gel pods
- A 7-inch perimeter foam encasement surrounding 6 inches of pocketed coils
The top three layers of the Wave Hybrid mattress are enhanced by high-performance airscape foam, resulting in a perfect blend of bounce and conforming. Below the Airscape foam is a polyfoam layer powered by targeted gel pods, which can respond to the body’s weight and provide customized support. The robust coils and perimeter support system ensure a lively feel and a secure edge for the bed.
Casper Element
At the opposite end of the price range from the Wave Hybrid is the Casper Element, a budget-friendly mattress option offered by the company. The Element has a medium-firm (6) feel and a simple construction consisting of two layers:
- 3 inches of Airscape polyfoam
- 6.5 inches of base polyfoam
Despite its straightforward design, the Element offers ample comfort and support through its thicker layer of Airscape polyfoam, which provides both contouring and responsiveness. While it may not have the specific tailoring features found in other Casper models, the Element is a highly comfortable and supportive mattress that appeals to budget-conscious shoppers.
Due to the diversity in mattress construction, it is natural for each model to have its own strengths and weaknesses. Instead of relying on an overall score, it is more beneficial to evaluate how mattresses perform in key categories.
We emphasize the following aspects of mattress performance as they greatly impact customer satisfaction. However, not all of these categories hold equal importance to every sleeper. To make an informed decision and effectively compare Nectar and Casper mattresses, consider your personal priorities within these categories.
Durability
The longevity of a mattress offers numerous benefits to owners. Firstly, it ensures that the mattress remains supportive and maintains quality sleep without sagging or wearing down. Secondly, a durable mattress allows you to postpone the need for a replacement, saving you money and maximizing your investment. Opting for a mattress with high-quality materials in all layers is the best choice for durability.
Motion Isolation
For those who share a bed, the disturbance caused by a partner’s tossing and turning can severely impact sleep quality. Motion isolation prevents this disruption by containing movement vibrations and preventing them from reaching the other side of the bed. Foam-based comfort systems, particularly those with memory foam, offer the highest level of motion isolation.
Sex
While sleep is the primary purpose of a bed, many individuals also value its ability to facilitate an active sex life. Not all mattresses are suitable for this activity, as a high level of bounce is essential. A mattress with excellent responsiveness and bounce is key for those seeking an optimal experience.
Temperature Neutrality
A temperature-neutral mattress prevents the buildup of excess heat during the night, which can lead to discomfort and excessive sweating. When a mattress clings tightly to the body and restricts airflow, it can cause overheating. Latex and hybrid mattresses are the top choices for temperature control, as they promote breathability. Traditional memory foam tends to retain heat, although newer memory foam beds are designed to minimize heat buildup.
Pressure Relief
A mattress must provide proper support by cushioning the body’s heaviest areas and relieving pressure points. Beds with moderate to significant contouring are often more effective in adapting to the body’s needs and promoting healthy spinal alignment.
Off-gassing
When a mattress is newly installed, it commonly emits a light odor known as the “new mattress smell.” This smell arises from the release of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) during the manufacturing process but poses no health risks. Although the odor is typically a minor annoyance, it can be problematic for individuals with allergies or sensitivities to smells. Low-quality foams tend to have the strongest off-gassing, but even with these mattresses, the odor typically dissipates within a few days.
Fluidity of Movement
When a mattress exhibits responsiveness, it swiftly returns to its original form as you shift and readjust your position on it. This elasticity lends an added boost to your movements, facilitating a smoother and more effortless experience. This quality proves particularly valuable for individuals who tend to change their sleeping positions frequently throughout the night.
Perimeter Support
For those seeking a sense of security while sleeping on any area of their mattress, it is crucial to consider edge support. A sturdy perimeter enables you to sit or lie near the edge without the fear of rolling onto the floor. Hybrid mattresses typically offer the most reliable edge support, while foam mattresses carry a higher risk of lacking in this aspect.
While some fortunate individuals can afford to spend any amount on a new mattress, most shoppers must adhere to a budget and carefully examine the price tag before making a selection.
One valuable piece of information for shoppers to bear in mind is that it is rare for mattresses to be sold at their full retail price. This price, also known as the manufacturer’s suggested retail price (MSRP), is usually reduced during checkout through sales, coupons, or promotional offers.
Having an understanding of the various factors influencing mattress pricing can also prove beneficial for shoppers. While not an exact formula, some of the key factors include:
- The composition and materials used in the mattress
- The quality of those components and materials
- Special features or innovative designs
- Eco-friendly or organic manufacturing processes
- Origin, whether the bed is made in the USA or abroad
The MSRP pricing for each mattress model offered by Nectar and Casper is detailed below. Both companies frequently provide discounts to reduce the actual price paid by their customers.
Exclusive Offer from the Sleep Foundation:
33% off on all purchases
Exclusive Offer from the Sleep Foundation:
Sleep Foundation readers receive the best price on Casper products
Based on the MSRP listings, Casper holds an advantage in terms of pricing. Their range includes more affordable options, suitable for those seeking entry-level or budget-friendly beds. The Casper Element stands out as their most economical model, offering a pocket-friendly solution for individuals looking to avoid spending excessively on a new mattress. The Casper Original is priced slightly lower than the Nectar Mattress, and the Casper Hybrid falls slightly on the higher end.
The Nectar Premier and Premier Copper are pricier than the Casper Element, Original, and Hybrid, but they remain less expensive than the Casper Nova Hybrid and the Casper Wave Hybrid. The Casper Nova Hybrid carries a price tag above the average for hybrid mattresses, while the Wave Hybrid is a luxurious product tailored to customers with ample budgets.
Nectar often provides substantial discounts and/or complimentary accessories to bridge the gap in MSRP pricing. Therefore, shoppers should carefully examine the promotions offered by both companies before making a final decision.
100 Nights (with a minimum requirement of 30 nights)
Free shipping to contiguous United States and Canadian provinces
When purchasing a new mattress, the practical aspects may not be the first consideration for most shoppers. Nonetheless, they warrant attention. Shipping, returns, and warranties are three central aspects to review. This section provides an overview of these factors for online mattress shopping and highlights the specific policies of Nectar and Casper.
When you order a mattress online, you can expect to receive it through standard shipping, which is sometimes referred to as mattress-in-a-box shipping. This type of shipping is typically included in the purchase and involves the mattress being delivered to your door within 1-2 weeks by ground shipping services.
To make the shipping process easier, the mattress is compressed, wrapped in plastic, and placed in a medium-sized box for delivery. For heavier mattresses, it usually takes a team of two or three people to safely move the box into your bedroom. Once the packaging is removed, the mattress will start to decompress and return to its full size.
Alternatively, you can choose White Glove delivery for an additional fee. This service includes in-home setup by a team of technicians who can even remove your old mattress if needed. However, not all companies offer White Glove services.
If you purchase a Nectar mattress, you will receive free mattress-in-a-box shipping within the contiguous United States. Shipping to Alaska and Hawaii is available but comes at an extra cost. If you opt for White Glove delivery, it will cost you $149, which covers the setup of the new mattress as well as the removal of an existing one.
Casper provides free standard shipping throughout the contiguous United States. However, if you need mattress-in-a-box shipping to Alaska, Hawaii, or Canada, there will be an additional charge. In some locations, expedited shipping is available for an extra fee. Casper also offers in-home delivery and setup for $149 in most parts of the contiguous United States. This service includes the installation of a Casper mattress and the removal of an old one.
One of the great advantages of buying a mattress online is the flexible return policies. Unlike retail stores where you can only try out a mattress briefly, online mattress companies offer sleep trials that allow you to test the bed for weeks or even months to see if it meets your needs. Most sleep trials last for 100 nights, and if you’re not satisfied with your purchase, returns are usually free, with a full refund provided. Some trials may require you to try the mattress for at least 30 days before initiating a return. If you decide to return a mattress, the company will typically coordinate a no-charge pickup or local donation.
Nectar takes their sleep trial to the next level by offering a full year to try out the mattress, with the option to return it for a full refund within that time. However, you must keep the bed for at least 30 nights before initiating a return. There are no return shipping fees, but extra charges associated with White Glove delivery are not refundable.
Casper’s sleep trial lasts for 100 nights and does not have a mandatory break-in period. If you’re not satisfied with the mattress at any point during the first 100 nights, you can request a return and receive a full refund. If you choose to add expedited shipping or White Glove delivery to your order, please note that those extra charges are non-refundable if you decide to return the mattress.
To provide peace of mind, nearly all online mattresses come with a warranty that lasts at least five years. The warranty covers defects in the mattress, and the company will either repair or replace the bed if a defect is found. However, damage caused by accidents or normal wear-and-tear is not considered a defect.
Some warranties may require the customer to cover certain costs associated with filing a warranty claim. A non-prorated warranty remains the same throughout its entire length, while a prorated warranty may have terms that change depending on how long you have owned the mattress.
Nectar mattresses come with a Forever Warranty. Within the first 10 years of ownership, the company will repair or replace a defective mattress at no cost to you. Starting in the 11th year, you will need to pay $50 for shipping each way, but this charge is waived if a mattress defect is confirmed.
Casper offers a 10-year non-prorated warranty on all their mattresses. If you experience any defects in your mattress, Casper will replace or repair it at no cost to you.
