2023 Comparison: Tempur-Pedic vs Sleep Number Mattress

By clicking on the links provided, you have the possibility to support us and earn a commission. Please note that the products or services being advertised on this page may be affiliated with us. If you want to find out more, you can click here.

There are few names in the mattress industry that carry as much weight as Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number. These two companies are giants in the field, known for their extensive product lines that revolve around unique mattress components.

For Tempur-Pedic, their defining component is TEMPUR memory foam, which they commercialized after its original invention by NASA. This material closely molds to the body, providing pressure relief, spinal support, and overall comfort. It is also excellent at minimizing motion transfer, ensuring that one person’s movements do not disturb their sleeping partner.

Sleep Number, on the other hand, distinguishes itself with its adjustable air chambers that form the support core of their mattresses. Sleepers can personalize the firmness of their bed by adding or removing air through a remote or smartphone app, until they find their ideal Sleep Number. Furthermore, for couples, each side of the bed has independent air chambers and controls, allowing individuals to set their preferred level of firmness.

Given the unique strengths of both these luxury mattress brands, it can be challenging to decide between them. Furthermore, with the wide range of models offered by each brand, it can be difficult to understand the differences and make an informed choice.

To assist you in making a decision, we have covered everything you need to know about Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number beds, including price, performance, and various other factors.

When comparing Sleep Number and Tempur-Pedic, it is beneficial to start with a high-level overview of these brands. The following table provides a quick glance and serves as a foundation for more detailed comparisons in the following sections.

We have made a concerted effort to present the best mattress options for you. Below, you will find our comprehensive mattress guides!

Price Range (Queen)

Firmness Options

Soft (3), Medium (5), Firm (7)

Adjustable – Soft (3) to Firm (8)

Standout Features

  • Durable and premium memory foam

  • Excellent contouring for pressure relief

  • Superb motion isolation

  • Real-time adjustments to firmness

  • Dual firmness design for couples

  • Gathers sleep data to enhance sleep quality

    Models

    Trial Period for Sleep and Warranty

    – 90 nights (requiring 30 nights)

    – Limited warranty for 10 years

    – 100 nights (30-night trial)

    – Limited warranty for 15 years

    Customer Service

    Exclusive Offer from the Sleep Foundation!

    Ready to make a purchase? Browse through Tempur-Pedic mattresses.

    Start Shopping Now

    Ready to make a purchase? Browse through Sleep Number mattresses.

    Start Shopping Now

    The weight of a mattress can impact its mobility, which may be a concern for those who anticipate frequently moving. The height of a mattress can also affect the fit of your sheets and your ease of getting in and out of bed, especially for individuals with knee, hip, or back pain.

    Selecting the appropriate mattress size directly influences your comfort in bed, the space in your bedroom, and the overall cost. While most mattresses come in the standard sizes of twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, and California king, there are exceptions within the product lines of Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number. Smaller sizes may not be available for certain models, and specialized non-standard options are offered for many mattresses.

    Tempur-Pedic

    Sleep Number

    Size Options

    – Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

    Size Options

    – Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, FlexTop King, FlexTop California King

    Size Options

    – Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King

    Size Options

    – Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, FlexTop King, FlexTop California King

    Size Options

    – Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, Split California King

    Size Options

    – Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, FlexTop King, Split California King

    Size Options

    – Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, Split California King

    Size Options

    – Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, FlexTop King, Split California King, FlexTop California King

    TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt

    Options for Sizing

    We have Twin XL, Queen, King, California King, Split King, and Split California King sizes available for you to choose from.

    p6

    Options for Sizing

    For our p6 mattress, we have sizes including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, FlexTop King, and Split California King.

    Size Options

    We offer Twin XL, Queen, King, California King, Split King, and Split California King sizes.

    i8

    Options for Sizing

    Our i8 mattress comes in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, FlexTop King, and Split California King sizes.

    Size Options

    Choose from our selection of Twin XL, Queen, King, California King, Split King, and Split California King sizes.

    i10

    Options for Sizing

    The i10 mattress is available in Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, FlexTop King, Split California King, and FlexTop California King sizes.

    Size Options

    We have a range of sizes for the i10 mattress, including Twin XL, Queen, King, California King, Split King, and Split California King.

    iLE

    Options for Sizing

    Our iLE mattress sizes include Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, FlexTop King, and Split California King.

    m7

    Options for Sizing

    Choose from our range of sizes for the m7 mattress, including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King, Split King, FlexTop King, Split California King, and FlexTop California King.

    Both Sleep Number and Tempur-Pedic provide a wide selection of mattresses. They have a similar range of heights, with no options that are exceptionally short or tall. Fitted sheets of regular sizes should fit these mattresses without any issues.

    The weight of the mattresses varies depending on the model. The listed weights are approximate and may differ based on the level of firmness chosen. Thicker mattresses have more materials and generally weigh more, while hybrid mattresses are heavier than all-foam beds.

    Although some models do not offer twin and full sizes, both Sleep Number and Tempur-Pedic have comprehensive product lines that cater to shoppers of all mattress sizes.

    Couples who prefer larger mattresses will be pleased to know that both brands offer split king and split California king sizes. These mattresses are designed with different feels on each side, providing added value to partners who have different preferences for mattress firmness.

    For most models, Sleep Number also offers a FlexTop king and FlexTop California king. The FlexTop feature means that instead of the mattress being fully split, only the head of the bed is separated. This allows the legs to be raised and lowered together on an adjustable base, while the heads can be set to different angles.

    The construction of a mattress is vital in determining its feel, performance, and durability. The construction includes the design of the layers and the actual materials used in those layers.

    In general, a mattress can be divided into two main sections:

    • The comfort system forms the top part and has the most immediate impact on the feel of the mattress. It is typically made of materials such as polyfoam, memory foam, latex, wool, cotton, and/or polyester.
    • The foundation layer is the lower segment of the bed. It influences the mattress sensation and the overall performance of the comfort system. Additionally, it helps prevent excessive sinking of the mattress. It can be manufactured using polyfoam, latex, innerspring coils, or air chambers.

    Both the comfort system and foundation layer may consist of one or several layers, which can be made of the same or different materials. Premium components in each layer contribute to avoiding weak links that hinder the overall mattress performance.

    The following sections provide an overview of the construction and materials used in Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number beds. While we have basic knowledge about their composition, both companies do not disclose all the specifications of their mattresses, making it challenging to make a comprehensive comparison between their models.

    A prominent component in Tempur-Pedic mattresses is TEMPUR foam, a type of visco-elastic foam commonly known as memory foam. This foam adjusts closely to the body, providing significant pressure relief and isolating motion.

    The original TEMPUR foam was initially developed by NASA and has been commercialized by Tempur-Pedic. The company has also introduced variations of the original foam. These variations include TEMPUR-ES (Extra Soft), TEMPUR-APR (Advanced Pressure Relief) for enhanced contouring, and TEMPUR-CM for improved ventilation with its porous structure.

    In the Adapt and Adapt Hybrid models, the comfort system consists of one layer of TEMPUR-ES and one layer of original TEMPUR foam. The support core is made of polyfoam in the Adapt model and pocketed innerspring coils in the Adapt Hybrid model, providing a more buoyant feel.

    In the LuxeAdapt, TEMPUR-ES or original TEMPUR foam (depending on the desired firmness) is layered above TEMPUR-APR and a polyfoam support core. The ProAdapt mattress features the top two layers of TEMPUR foam, which can be ES, APR, or original depending on the desired firmness, and a polyfoam support core. The ProAdapt Hybrid combines TEMPUR-ES and TEMPUR-APR foams with a pocketed innerspring support core.

    All models with “Breeze” in their names incorporate features to reduce heat retention. One of these features is Phase Change Material (PCM), which regulates temperature by absorbing or dissipating heat. This material, along with the breathable cover, promotes moisture-wicking and provides cooling comfort.

    The PRObreeze and PRObreeze Hybrid mattresses utilize a top layer of TEMPUR-CM foam, which has a more porous structure, allowing increased airflow to prevent heat buildup. This layer is supported by the original TEMPUR foam. The support core is made of polyfoam in the PRObreeze model and pocketed coils in the PRObreeze Hybrid model.

    The LUXEbreeze, Tempur-Pedic’s most luxurious option, shares the same cooling features as the PRObreeze models, including the PCM-infused cover. It also features TEMPUR-CM as its top component. What sets this mattress apart is its second layer of foam, which utilizes ventilated TEMPUR-APR for improved breathability and contouring.

    While most Tempur-Pedic mattresses are composed entirely of foam, there are three hybrid options available. These hybrid mattresses utilize an innerspring core, providing more bounce and edge support compared to the all-foam beds. The presence of coils minimizes heat retention, resulting in slightly cooler sleep than an all-foam model. However, due to the increased bounce, hybrids may transfer more motion.

    Tempur-Pedic memory foams have long been regarded as a benchmark in the industry. Although the company does not disclose the thickness or density of their foam layers, customer reviews indicate their durability and ability to withstand years of nightly use.

    When discussing the Sleep Number product line, it is essential to highlight the air chamber support core as the defining feature of these mattresses. An attached pump allows for rapid inflation or deflation of the air chamber, instantly altering the mattress’s feel.

    The pump can be controlled via a smartphone app or a remote control that displays a single number known as the Sleep Number. Higher numbers correspond to a firmer feel. Once individuals identify their preferred setting, they typically maintain a consistent Sleep Number. However, one advantage of these mattresses is the ability to make real-time adjustments as desired.

    An additional crucial aspect of the support core is the presence of separate air chambers on both sides of the bed in all full-size or larger mattresses. These air chambers allow for independent control of Sleep Numbers, ensuring that each individual in a couple can experience their desired level of comfort.

    Technology plays a significant role in Sleep Number beds. They are equipped with a SleepIQ system that collects data on your sleep patterns, provides a daily score, and identifies areas for improvement. The bed also has auto-adjustment capabilities, which enable it to detect changes in your support needs throughout the night and adjust the Sleep Number accordingly.

    All Sleep Number mattresses have a foam comfort system positioned above the air chambers. The total thickness of the comfort system is disclosed, although specific details about the materials and layering are not provided. In most models, polyfoam or gel-infused polyfoam is used, except for the m7, which incorporates memory foam in at least a portion of the comfort system. The table below shows the thickness of the foam comfort system in each model.

    SeriesModelComfort System ThicknessClassicc22″Classicc43″Performancep54″PerformancepSE4″Performancep65″Innovationi86″InnovationiLE6″Innovationi107″Memory Foamm75″The Classic Series possesses all the key features of Sleep Number beds, including dual air chambers, auto-adjustment capabilities, and the SleepIQ technology. The Performance Series, as displayed in the previous table, shares these features but also offers a thicker comfort system.

    The Innovation Series encompasses all the features of the Performance line while incorporating additional pressure-relieving foam. These models also feature PCM-type material aimed at enhancing temperature regulation.

    A thicker comfort system, like those found in the Performance and Innovation series, can provide better contouring, motion isolation, and stress reduction on the support core. However, it may decrease the sensitivity to changes when adjusting the Sleep Number. Furthermore, taller models tend to be the most expensive within the Sleep Number product range.

    If you prefer using a remote rather than the Sleep Number app, you must purchase it separately. The remote is covered by its own two-year warranty. Setting up the SleepIQ system requires connecting it to your home WiFi network.

    To select the best mattress for yourself, it’s important to know what to consider. This will allow you to understand how a mattress will feel and impact your sleep, helping you determine your top priorities and requirements.

    When evaluating and comparing different options, consider the following features, especially when comparing Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number beds:

    • Durability: Signs of wear and tear, such as sagging, can lead to discomfort and improper spinal alignment. Poor durability may necessitate the premature purchase of a new mattress. The quality of materials is a critical factor affecting a mattress’s longevity, and a well-constructed mattress should last for at least five years.
    • Motion Isolation: Motion isolation is essential for reducing disturbances caused by movement on the mattress, especially for couples. A comfort system, particularly one with memory foam, plays a central role in minimizing motion transfer and offering superior motion isolation.
      • Intimacy: For many individuals, a mattress serves more than just a sleep aid. When it comes to couples, having a mattress that doesn’t hinder their active sex life is a common priority. The ideal mattress for intimacy is one that offers responsiveness, creating a sense of bouncing when in motion. However, certain materials like memory foam or other low-responsiveness polyfoams can make one feel trapped, restricting movement and potentially causing issues during intimate moments.
      • Temperature Regulation: Maintaining a neutral temperature while sleeping is crucial, especially for those who tend to sleep hot. Heat retention can disrupt sleep and create discomfort, particularly with materials that contour deeply, reducing airflow around the body. Traditional memory foam is also prone to retaining heat. To combat this, manufacturers often incorporate ventilation and breathability features in mattresses to keep them cooler.
      • Relief from Pressure: Every individual’s body has certain points that experience greater impact with the mattress. If these points are not properly cushioned, it can lead to discomfort and even misalignment of the spine. When a mattress offers proportional cushioning based on weight distribution, like memory foam, it provides effective pressure relief. This is especially beneficial for side sleepers and individuals dealing with pain and pressure points.
      • Odor Control: During the production process, certain aspects of mattress manufacturing can release volatile organic compounds (VOCs), resulting in a distinct odor. While not harmful to health, some people find the smell bothersome. The odor, often referred to as “new mattress smell,” typically diminishes within a few hours. However, individuals who are highly sensitive to smells may find this issue more significant.
      • Easy Movement: If you tend to switch between different sleeping positions or simply enjoy moving around on your bed, ease of movement becomes a crucial factor. Mattresses with higher responsiveness and less sinkage are better suited for effortless movement and mobility on the bed.
      • Edge Support: Weak edge support is a common problem in many mattresses, making it challenging to feel stable while sitting or sleeping near the edges. This lack of support can make even a larger mattress feel smaller, as less surface area is usable. Certain materials, such as soft foams, are more susceptible to excessive compression around the edges. Coil-based support cores and perimeter foam reinforcements can greatly enhance edge support.

      In the following tables, you can observe the comparative performance of Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number mattresses in these specific categories.

      Making an informed decision when purchasing a mattress is crucial for both your sleep quality and your budget. Mattresses come in a wide price range, and selecting wisely ensures that you obtain a good value regardless of your budgetary constraints.

      Numerous factors can influence the price of a mattress, including its materials, design, features, country of origin, and delivery method. Mattresses with specialized components often come with a higher price tag.

      It’s important for shoppers to note that the sticker retail price (MSRP) seldom reflects the actual amount customers pay. Deals and discounts are frequently available, particularly when purchasing online, giving customers ample time to conduct thorough research and diligently compare different mattress options and their respective price points. Online platforms often offer promotions and discounts without the need for haggling or negotiation.

      While both Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number beds fall into the luxury segment of the market, there is still significant price variation within the product lines of these two companies.

      The tables below display the retail prices of Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number mattresses across various sizes.

      Sleep Foundation Special Offer

      Ready to make a purchase? Explore Tempur-Pedic mattresses

      Sleep Foundation Special Offer

      Ready to make a purchase? Explore Tempur-Pedic mattresses

      The price range for Sleep Number and Tempur-Pedic mattresses is above average compared to most mattresses sold online. These brands are considered luxury options with well-established reputations. Although they frequently offer deals, they are not classified as budget products.

      With that being said, Sleep Number offers more affordable choices, particularly the c2 and, to a lesser extent, the c4. These options are appealing for individuals who desire adjustable firmness without breaking the bank. While the c2 and c4 have a thinner comfort system, this may not matter as much for those weighing under 230 pounds who require less cushioning.

      On the other hand, Sleep Number also offers the most expensive beds, especially in larger and more complex sizes like the Split King. These pricier models come with robust comfort systems.

      Tempur-Pedic does not have options as affordable as the c2 or c4 from Sleep Number. However, the performance of TEMPUR foam can justify the higher cost for individuals who value the feel of memory foam. The newer iterations of Tempur-Pedic’s foams contribute to the cost in models like the LUXEbreeze.

      90 nights (30-night requirement)

      Free White Glove delivery to all contiguous U.S. locations

      100 nights (30-night trial)

      $199 for White Glove delivery to all 50 states

      The process and logistics of purchasing a mattress online differ from the traditional in-store experience. While buying online is usually more convenient, some confusion can arise regarding the details.

      The following sections address commonly asked questions for first-time mattress online shoppers.

      Most online mattresses come compressed and shipped in a mattress-in-a-box directly to customers’ doorsteps. However, Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number are exceptions as luxury brands with extensive mattress delivery experience. Both brands offer White Glove delivery.

      White Glove delivery means that the company schedules a delivery time with the customer. Technicians then arrive to install the mattress, remove the old one, and take away any related packaging materials.

      Tempur-Pedic provides free White Glove delivery with mattress purchases. Sleep Number, on the other hand, charges $199 for White Glove delivery, which customers need to factor into their total budget.

      Customers residing outside the 48 contiguous U.S. states or in certain remote areas may have limited and/or expensive delivery options.

      Tempur-Pedic offers White Glove delivery to Alaska and Hawaii for an additional charge of $600. Sleep Number does not provide their White Glove delivery service to Hawaiian addresses. For remote locations and Alaska, Sleep Number may offer delivery and installation at an extra cost dependent on the specific location.

      One of the main differences between buying online and in-store is the inability to try the bed before making a purchase. Instead, customers have a sleep trial period during which they can test the mattress at home with the option to return it for a refund.

      Having an in-home sleep trial allows customers to experience the mattress in real-world conditions for an extended period, providing a clearer sense of its suitability compared to a brief trial in a mattress store. During the trial, customers can return the mattress if they are not satisfied, with the company usually sending someone to pick it up.

      Both Tempur-Pedic and Sleep Number offer sleep trials with their mattresses.

      – Tempur-Pedic provides customers with 90 nights to try the mattress at home. They are required to keep the mattress for 30 nights before initiating a return. If they decide not to keep it, there is a $175 charge for return shipping.

      – Sleep Number offers customers 100 nights for a sleep trial and requires them to keep the mattress for 30 nights before initiating a return. The return shipping charge for Sleep Number beds ranges from $199 to $249.

      A warranty protects customers from being stuck with a defective product. If a component breaks down due to a defect in materials or manufacturing, the warranty provides a remedy through repair or replacement of the mattress.

      It is important for customers to understand that warranties do not cover normal changes or wear and tear on a mattress; they only address true defects.

      The length and terms of a warranty can vary. Some warranties may decrease coverage based on the duration of ownership, known as a prorated warranty. In contrast, non-prorated warranties maintain the same coverage throughout the entire warranty term.

      Tempur-Pedic offers a non-prorated 10-year warranty. If a defect arises within this time, Tempur-Pedic will repair or replace the mattress. Customers are only responsible for any shipping charges related to the warranty claim.

      Sleep Number provides a prorated 25-year warranty for their mattresses. In the first two years, it offers full coverage of repair or replacement costs. From years 3 to 20, customers gradually bear a larger portion of the repair or replacement costs, starting at 20% and increasing by 4% annually. From years 21 to 25, customers cover 96% of the costs. Starting in year three, customers are also responsible for shipping costs. The warranties for the SleepIQ system and remote control last for two years and are non-prorated.

      While the Sleep Number warranty lasts longer, it offers less coverage, especially after the first two years of ownership. In the latter part of the warranty, customers shoulder a significant share of costs, diminishing the value of the coverage. After two years, customers also bear the full cost of any issues with the SleepIQ system or remote control.

See also  Battle of the Beds: Awara vs. PlushBeds Botanical Bliss Mattress Comparison 2023